After the Stand-in Shou Faked His Death

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

Xu ChengYan had been together with the eldest young master of the He family for five years, always on call and he yielded to everything. Even though He Yang always treated him with a cold face, Xu ChengYan was willing, thinking that as long as he was the most special one to He Yang, one day he would be able to melt the iceberg.

Until one day, He Yang’s white moonlight returned to China.

Xu ChengYan saw with his own eyes that the man who was always cold and indifferent in front of him was extremely gentle in front of the white moonlight. It was also at this time that Xu ChengYan realized that he was just a substitute. Icebergs will melt, but the person who melted this iceberg was not him. The exhausted Xu ChengYan finally woke up. He chose to let go, packed his luggage and left by himself.

And when He Yang came back and saw the empty apartment, he just smiled and made a bet with the group of good-for-nothing friends: within five days, Xu ChengYan will come back.

On the first day, Xu ChengYan did not come back. The next day, Xu ChengYan still didn’t come back.

On the fifth day, Xu ChengYan finally returned. It was just that what was waiting for He Yang was Xu ChengYan’s icy cold corpse, which could no longer be recovered.

Three years later, He Yang was still the aloof and indifferent eldest young master of the He family.

At a banquet, He Yang suddenly saw a familiar figure. He Yang lost his self-control, rushed forward like a madman, and stood in front of the black-haired young man.

“Yanyan.”

The eldest young master of the He family, who had always been indifferent, was holding the young man’s hand tightly at this time, his eyes were slightly red.

“Go back with me, okay?”

The dazzling black-haired youth just smiled and moved the man’s hand away.

“Sorry Sir, you have mistaken the wrong person.”

Associated Names
One entry per line
I’m A Stand-In Puppet For His Ex-Lover
Quan hệ thế thân
Sau đó thế thân thụ giả chết
Stand-in Relationship
The Substitute Relationship
ในวันที่ตัวสำรองจากไป
替身关系
替身受假死之后
Related Series
N/A
Recommendations
Before My Withering (1)
Professional Body Double (1)
My Foolish Snake Husband Wouldn’t Stop Pestering Me (1)
Dressed as a Stand-in for the White Moonlight (1)
Recommendation Lists
  1. love me a good chase, regret and repent you scums!
  2. Black/Red flags bl
  3. dookie mls
  4. Crematorium, wife-chasing BL
  5. unfinished and like (could take off not likes late...

Latest Release

Date Group Release
03/30/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c151-38
03/26/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c150-37
03/23/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c149-36
03/19/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c148-35
03/16/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c147
03/12/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c146
03/09/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c145
03/04/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c144
01/05/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c143
01/01/25 Chrysanthemum Garden c142
12/29/24 Chrysanthemum Garden c141
12/28/24 Chrysanthemum Garden c140
12/01/24 Chrysanthemum Garden c139
11/27/24 Chrysanthemum Garden c138
11/24/24 Chrysanthemum Garden c137
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
60 Reviews sorted by


Nonameschemer
Nonameschemer rated it
September 9, 2022
Status: --
Not the worse, but the author tries so HARD to white wash the ML it gives me whiplash.

There was SO much whitewashing, I complied a short list, that probably doesn't encompass all of the dirty laundry from the ML the author had to clean to make things a "perfect" misunderstanding but keeping in all of the angst.

... more>>
Spoiler

1. The ML "didn't want to fall in love, so he blindfolded the MC in bed.

2. ML was looking at the scrapbook because of his mom totally not because he still had feelings for "White moonlight" who turns out to be his savior of sorts ???

3. Was never in love with his white moonlight, he just felt grateful for him.

4. Dresses the MC up like the love rival because of his dead mom or whatever.

5. Gave the MC cake from love rival's favorite bakery because the MC smiled once when he gave him cake, so he assumes he likes sweets

[collapse]

I honestly docked off a whole point for such tomfoolery. If you want a s*um gong, please, just write him a s*um gong and have a satisfying grovel fest. To me, its like the author thinks we, the reader are idiots and the characters settings personalities are really there just for show when you change things at a snap just for fun. The ML seemed really in love with their white moonlight, platonic and affection are not so easily mistook. I really love a s*um gong who's actually scum, whats the point of reading dog blood dramas if you want squeaky clean characters all the time?

Another reason why I deducted another point is because of the plot twist

Spoiler

So, you just expect us to believe that they didn't do a proper autopsy on a patient? I couldn't suspend my disbelief for that scene because MC just so naturally took up someone's entire existence despite this person realistically having photo Id, finger prints, etc. Identity theft doesn't happen by accident

[collapse]

I will say the plot twist adds a bit of depth to MC though. He did a really f-ed up thing, but I understand why he did it. Human beings are selfish and simply want comfort, connection, and love even if the method on how such things are obtained isn't the most ethical.

However! This book is still a solid 3 star because of the way the ML dealt with grief. It was actually heartbreaking and evoked a lot emotion from me, a seasoned veteran in reading dogblood tragedy p*rn novels. The MLs grief was written highly realistic and I can tell the author put in some research into mental health/grieving and or had some experience with it. Which is something CN light novels are notoriously bad at. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
bougaris
bougaris
November 5, 2024
Status: --
Read:

  • For the ab*se, grief, and angst.
  • A doormat just being a doormat.
  • The most Olympic level acrobatics to explain why these two should stay together.
The best part of this story is the beginning. We watch as our MC realizes how crappy is relationship is. His stoic boyfriend seems very animated and caring when his old friend returns. It's honestly heartbreaking when he realizes that his clothes, the glasses (that he doesn't need), even the food he's given are things this guy likes. Dude has not only been a doormat for the entire... more>> relationship because love but an highly uncommunicative one at that. I'm sorry, but if you allow your boyfriend to constantly buy you food you don't like and eat it because got you something. I feel like you need as much therapy as our ML.

The worst part is the ML. The story attempts to explain away all his shitty behaviours behind the veneer of mental illness, trauma, and misunderstanding but he never does two things. One, acknowledge what he did was wrong and Two, attempt to fix all the bad behavior. Yes, his grief was delicious but as soon as he sees our boy he immediately goes into an obsessive stalker mode and does everything to tie our MC to his side. Nothing he does ever shows that he actually cared for MC. It felt more that he just like that someone liked him. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Ainslee
Ainslee
July 22, 2022
Status: --
I don't like mentally abusive relationship. Several initial chapters of this novel was exactly the type that I abhorred.

You need to value yourself before expecting others to value you.

Hopefully MC realized that it's being good to himself more important than the smokescreen of love given by the ML (if that man was the real ML) 🙄

MTL up to chapter 95, readability 85%...

Author was really an example of stepmother author. The abusive and the willingness to be ab*sed characters in this novel was overwhelming.

No wonder reviewers gave low rating.
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Kassandra
Kassandra rated it
June 6, 2022
Status: c83
OKAY! I tried this because I'm in the mood to cry. And I really cried for the first 30 chapters. (They're the painful part.)

I've read the bad and good reviews and I think, the novel is quite good.

I stopped on chapters 83.

(Might or might not continue it, I'll update when I continue it. The probability was low tho.)

... more>>
Spoiler

Chapter 83 – Where He Yang proposed to ChengYan and he (XCY) rejected it.

[collapse]

I just feel that's the best ending for them. Open ended ending where it leaves to the reader's imagination what will happen to them, whether its a happy or bad ending.

Tho I know they'll end up together in the end.

I love how the Author switch the names Xu ChengYan and Qin Zhou, it makes me feel like YanYan is really Qin Zhou. I also love how the Author explained the misunderstandings. She made it straight to the readers clearly and I, understood it.

He Yang, in my understanding, wasn't good with words, doesn't like to explain, and have a low EQ. Like an autism, that's why they had various misunderstandings. His experience with his family also adds up, where his mother died and his father became a mess, that's tough. Xu Chengyan, I LOVE THE TRANSFORMATION!! He quickly went from soft to tough and firm!
Spoiler

I TELL YOU I'M ACTUALLY SURPRISED THAT HE REJECTED HE YANG'S PROPOSAL.

I'm like: (◯Δ ◯ ∥)

[collapse]

I also love Jiang Lin!! HE'S THE SWEETEST! A cutie pie. (I kinda shipped him with Yuan Lie, the doctor.)

And QiQi, AAAAAAAAAAH! One of my fave! I just have a soft spot for dogs. He quickly entered my heart the moment I read him.
Spoiler

I cried really really hard when he always wait at the car, waiting for ChengYan to appear and to play with him like always.

[collapse]

He's so loyal, I'm inlove!~

Anyway, recommended for people who love things like this, you know who you are. And also recommending it for peeps wanting to cry but doesn't have a reason to, c'mon!

Bye bye, YanYan!~

(From your mother fan.)

Bye, He Yang.

Treat YanYan well.

BYE QIQI! Qaq

I'll miss you! [Blows_on_the_handkerchied. Jpeg] <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
iyok
iyok rated it
March 7, 2022
Status: c52
Dropped. Read up to the middle of chapter 52.

To be fair, it's probalbly a four star? But the ML was so unsatisfactory so I dedcuted two... >__>

If you're looking for a novel where MC is strong mentally (and you like being ab*sed emotionally) then this is for you.

Replying to Olieejiyeon-nim, ... more>>
Spoiler

I think one part of the reason the MC chose to become QZ was because of QZ's grandpa (or grandma? the MTL randomly changed their gender every chapter. argh.) When they first met, the granny mistook him for QZ and was really nice to him. This probably gave him ideas. It also made him feel guilty cuz he's part of the reason that QZ's dead. So he took on the role of QZ, tried to become the 2nd QZ and tried really hard to support the granny. Even thought of selling his body so the granny could get treatment...

I saw red herrings that the granny's soon gonna recognize that he's not the real QZ and then his cover's gonna blow. *smirking raccon rub hands. jpg*

[collapse]

I need 2nd ML. lol I really dislike He Yang. I hope
Spoiler

Emporer Pei

[collapse]
became 2nd love interest or something. The dog was really adorable. Two of the stars is for it.

He Yang was such an a**hole. He treated MC like sh*t. He didn't protect him from being badmouthed or ridiculed while they were together. HY didn't care of the MC's existence when he's with the white moonlight. For him, the MC is probably a convenient hole to plunge his dirty member into when he's h*rny. I mean, he went out to meet the moonlight, then came back home to f*ck the MC cuz he couldn't really f*ck the "childhood friend who's really weak".

When the MC died, I understand he didn't show remorse because he's so deep in denial, but still... I hope this b*stard repented a lot. I mean, A LOT.

I won't be happy, in fact, I think I'll be mad as hell if they ended up together...

Yea, and like the other reader said, the MC personalities changed too drastically and so suddenly. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
XD
XD rated it
February 3, 2022
Status: c80
I want a novel where the ML was super regretful and apologized, as in acknowledging what he did wrong and apologized. I feel like the author missed a chance here by making the majority of the drama a result of misunderstandings.
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
deicide.
deicide. rated it
November 19, 2023
Status: Completed
I truly don't think it's as bad as the rating is. (prob not 5 star but not as low as 3.5.)

it's a standard wife chasing crematorium/stand-in fiasco.

long story short and maybe a spoiler? MC isn't a stand in, the ML has fking low EQ and obv doesn't set boundaries.

explanation on why he isn't a stand in and what I understood from the story:

... more>>
Spoiler

the clothes, accessories and perfume was never the 'white moonlight's' aesthetic. the clothes were from a brand that ML's mother's company has. every year, the company would send the new collection in MC's sizes to ML and what the 'white moonlight' had was merely bought from his own money.

why the ML treats the 'white moonlight' well, from young, although the kidnapping incident happened, it was mentioned by ML that the two kids took care of each other but the media exaggerated that the 'white moonlight' took the brunt of it. anyway, ML'S family is obv strong and thus his elders always told him, when young, that he should treat the guy well and take care of him well. (much like brainwashing ig and it stayed with him.)

ofc I'm not trying to invalidate MC's feelings and I still think the reasoning is bull but it gives an insight. the ML obv has trouble trying to sort out his emotions, when his mother died, he threw away the camera, bcs his mother loved taking pictures, and was stoic through the whole thing.

ML's group of friends truly s**ked and I'm pretty sure he didn't give a damn about them but just goes out to feel some sort of hussle and bustle.

in the end, ML decided that enough was enough and cut out the 'white moonlight' and he never appeared until the end bcs ML basically forbid him from reentering Nancheng, 'white moonlight called to ask if he could come back' and basically ML asked MC and ML said he'd listen to MC. so he never came back. this part got me 🫠 bcs idk how I feel about it. like can't ML do it himself and not just listen to MC? but ig I understand it. anyways.

oh and the blindfold and doggy style was basically just his s*xual preference in some sense. doggy, bcs the position felt good and he could reach deeper and blindfold, I couldn't rly understand the mtl... it was kinda said in passing in later chapters (towards the end ig), as he didn't like seeing him cry (prob during sex) but now he does. (or he actually liked the eyes but smth smth. idk.)

not kissing was bcs he wasn't in love with the MC at that time and said kissing was too intimate (for bed partners) but he grew to love him over the 5 years but took it for granted.

MC knew they were only bed partners bcs that's what they agreed on at first.

[collapse]

anyways, I quite like how the story went, it didn't focus much on others and rly just focused on our mains. it depicted their emotions and how they tried to 'work it out.' mostly, how psychologically damaged they both were. I enjoyed it hah.

I feel like the ML is really too emotionally dumb LOL. but when he kept staying around the MC and not trying to separate, I'm sorry to say but it's quite cute. ML grew on me as the story went by. it was quite cute and I kinda hate myself for it.

but the MC, I feel, was quite strong and yet weak. he knew that it was wrong and set boundaries, although ML didn't rly listen but MC did kinda just indulge since he rly did like him, and the ML did try to separate when MC asked.

the first 100 chapters was quite sad and I cried a number of times. towards the end I did cry again bcs of Jiang Lin, ML's cousin, and our MC's interaction with regards to names.

I will say I really love Jiang Lin alot... he was the kind of character I always wanted to see in these kinds of story. to let the MC have someone stand by their side.

istg I prob would've typed the whole damn story in the spoiler if I wasn't on my phone and lazy hahaha. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Eueu
Eueu rated it
September 24, 2022
Status: c51
Went here just rant about how I hate the Yuan Lie guy aka the psychologist of the ML.

... more>>
Spoiler

He's incompetent and keeps giving useless "real talk" advice. The ML has been having hallucinations of the MC for years and this guy just kept advising to start a new life and move on. He also keeps breaching patient-doctor confidentiality by sharing to ML details about his other patient, the ML's cousin. He also keeps badgering ML to take his counseling services. Everytime they meet! And even when they're in public. Lyk, why don't you just advertise that the ML has been seeing a therapist. I know it's not shameful to have one but some ppl don't want it advertised in public ok?! He's also too nosey and meddlesome but I don't see genuine concern for his patients. Because if he has, he should've referred ML to another specialist because ML was obviously not getting better and he's obviously incompetent.

There's also a part where he had to close his clinic because he didn't have a client anymore since the ML stopped going there. Lolol I wonder why he doesn't have clients..... 😅😅

[collapse]

Anyway, because of how much I hate this guy, I disliked the ML a little less. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Dariie
Dariie rated it
July 14, 2022
Status: Completed
One of my favorite dog blood novels! I almost didn't read this because of the negative reviews, I mean their reviews are not completely unreasonable tho. But I have my own reasons why I liked this novel.

I saw some reviews criticizing the ML and the MC, yes what they said is true. But for me they're just fine, they have their own faults, but because of that, I find them more human and realistic.

I hated the ML at the early chapters too but near the end of the novel,

... more>>
Spoiler

The author kinda explained the reason for his sc*m behavior towards the mc

[collapse]

And one of the reasons why I can't completely hate the ML is because I think he suffered enough? Enough to redeem himself. It's kinda rare for a novel of regret genre to have an ML like that, that's why I can't hate him.

If you do love dog blood and regret novels, give this novel a chance! Also the manhua of this novel is out, so you can try to read it if you want~ <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
veijun
veijun rated it
June 19, 2022
Status: c136
Wtf happened 😭😭 I really enjoyed this story up until ... more>>
Spoiler

the ML suddenly starts treating the MC like a kid and comparing everything he does to a kid, like because the MC has insomnia he is supervised while going to bed like he's just a kid throwing a tantrum because it doesn't want to sleep??? I especially don't understand where the insensitivity of the ML comes from since he also went through insomnia before... also when the dog does things he isn't allowed to and doesn't usually do while only MC is at home it's the fault of MC, because he is a naughty kid who can't be left alone at home...??? And so on... this f*cking weirded me out. And also how the MC never cleared up all the stuff thats been troubling him in their past relationship but still doesn't reject the ML anymore... I mean the relationship just seriously got weird after MC fulfilled Qin Zhou's dreams. Even before that, the explanation of why the ML treated the MC like that before wasn't satisfactory and other stuff that got on my nerves... and the MC isn't even really bothered but just goes with the flow

[collapse]
It's so frustrating because I really enjoyed the story before despite a few dubious plot points but now I don't really want to read it anymore and might just stop. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
probablyanna80
probablyanna80 rated it
June 8, 2022
Status: c117
I'm putting this on hold. I'm not sure if I'll pick it back up. Giving it 2 stars since I did make it this far. I know I'm so close to completeing it, but I feel a little mentally exhausted at the thought of still having to read 77 more chapters to do so.

There is so much redundency in this novel. It defintely doesn't need to be close to 200 chapters. I lost count how many times the MC rejected the ML over the years of their separation. At one... more>> point, the MC did
Spoiler

sleep with the ML for 3 months

[collapse]
but still rejected him over and over and over again. I also lost count with how many times the MC had a fever because it was another thing that happened over and over again.

I really disliked the ML at first, but things were explained and...
Spoiler

the "white moonlight" really wasn't one. The reason why the MC and "white moonlight" dressed alike was explained. Although I'm still confused as to why the ML would sometimes have the MC wear glasses when he doesn't need them and the "white moonlight" needed them. I can accept the other excuses about the clothes, their bed activities, etc. but I just don't get the glasses.

[collapse]

The ML starts out the the EQ of a boiled turnip and has some progress. This is the only crematorium novel, and I've read many, where I did want the ML to move on with someone else and the MC can just focus on himself. At one point late into the novel,
Spoiler

the MC thought the ML had a new boyfriend and the MC just did not care at all.

[collapse]
That's when I was ready for the ML to find another relationship.

If someone wants to read this, then I'd recommend do not binge read it due to the repetative plot points.

To end this on a bit of a positive note, this is an easier novel to MTL if someone doesn't want to wait for the fan translation. Another thing to put in the "pro" column is that both the MC and ML have 180 degree character changes from where they start in the novel. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
fudanshii18
fudanshii18 rated it
May 7, 2022
Status: c119
MC feels inferior to the ML. ML deliberately made MC as a subtitute to his white moonlight by making him dress the same thing. His friends even have prejudice against MC which shows that ML is really making MC as a stand in. When they have s*x he always put tie to cover MC’s eyes because with cover the face looks similar to the white moonlight, his body shape too. Where is the love? I don’t get why people hate MC when in fact, they should hate ML more. Both... more>> of them have their faults so why attack MC only? ML clearly said that he is not in that kind of relationship with the white moonlight and he added that he and MC are also not lovers. What the f##k. He stayed with you for 5 years, yet he wasn’t able to move you? Are you a stone? Don’t worry, MC did feel happy in those 5 years, because he thinks the ML likes him too. (He said this at chapter 107)

In fact, ML did not treat MC as a substitute, even if that is the case, his attitude towards MC is really unexplainable and unacceptable. He explained all the reason why he did those to MC at chapter 79. Still, I felt like it’s not genuine. When the MC asks questions to ML about the WM he always avoid it and doesn’t have a clear answer. Well, in the perspective as an outsider, I can see that he doesn’t really like the WM, but I’m not the MC (lol. Poor MC)

ML was very cold to him and his friends hates MC. Why is that so? MC has never done anything wrong so the problem lies with the ML. Even when he hears his friends bad mouthing MC, he just brushes it off like it has nothing to do with him. MC may seem like a masochist but he is not. He just loves ML more than himself.

What's wrong with getting STD test? It's health, duh. MC demanded that both of them to test.

He never said anything because before MC and ML became friends with benefits, MC agreed with the ML that he is fine without a label. He is obedient to him. He never bothered to tell ML what he likes and dislikes. MC is at fault, yes, but he did what he said to ML that he will be obedient. ML also said to his friends at the start that MC is JUST a PLAYTHING. It’s just MC’s wishful thinking that ML likes him too.

"I don't care about your relationship with others." We can depict this as an angry remarks or just MC's true feeling. ML kept bothering him when MC doesn't want to go back together with him. I really want to strangle ML because it's him who is the cause of this drama, not the WM. Why? Because as a friend, would you stay overnight together with a friend? Being in an ambigous relationship. The WM can't do anything if only ML just distance himself for a bit to him.

ML proposed to him but it was already 3 years late and doesn't want it now. He refused him to pursue what he wants to do in his life. A future without ML. Their situation reversed. The ML is now the person who is lovesick and MC is the cold and indifferent.

The sudden 360 change of attitude of MC after he faked death is totally understandable. A lot of things can happen in the 3 years he and ML were apart. He has a lot of time to think and realize things in that span of time. A quiet person is even scarier than others because you never know what they might be thinking. He has repressed all his emotions for the past 5 years with ML. Always a perfect lover to ML, but he doesn’t want to do that now. It is not clarified in the novel what he really is like. If it involves the ML, he is timid and just a piano teacher. What about if it doesn’t involve ML?

MC was actually scouted by an agent and asked if he want to be an idol but he refused because he was already with ML at that time and he is worried that he will not have time for the ML, so he refused. Now in his second chance of life, he became an actor. He is really destined to shine but it was just that ML was his priority before.

BUT! The healing started when the WM is chased by ML to go abroad. ML did everything he can just for the MC to fall in love with him again. He did not try to force him but he always let himself be in the presence. Both ML and MC became more mature and we can really see their character development.

The novel is full of plot holes and I have to lower my standard just to drop it halfway. I stopped reading at chapter 119 since it’s gotten really boring and I know that they’ll get married at the end. It’s a happy ending! <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Keikey
Keikey
March 4, 2022
Status: --
MC is so in love it's pathetic how he accepts not being treated better by ML. But it's still bearable to read. Until the white moonlight enters d the scene. He has suspicions he's a substitute then it's verified but he still couldn't let go. Then the story is interesting because the white moonlight is not what he seems to be. But what is boring is that ML wants MC back but MC refuses and is nevertheless unable of keeping ML away despite the 3 years apart because ML has... more>> money and touchy Feely.

And when they get beck together is like on MC 's whim, so sudden, then the rest of the story is not interesting. Like ML is unable to extract himself from the past and MC is only interested in s*x roleplay. As some readers said, the story is too long, and there's drama only in the beginning.

The s*x scenes are not interesting, and too censored BTW.

Too long and headaching nonsense that's I haven't finished it.

4 stars for the turnabout and for making my eyes puffy in the first arc <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Nao Otosaka
Nao Otosaka
February 2, 2022
Status: Completed
Sigh... that's what was my first reaction when I completed reading this. It.. has its fair share of plotholes and things which do not really board well with me.

Spoiler

Cons:

  • The first point is obviously the drama aspect of the story. The first 30-some chapters is based off on the MC's 'dubious' relationship with ML. He's in a relationship where ML is reluctant to recognise/identify MC (and if you have read enough CN novels then you might realise what I'm hinting at here). MC is head over heels in love with ML to the point he never questions their unnamed/unrecognised relationship for the past 5 years. ML on the other hand brushes off MC's existence as someone who's just there to cater to him. ML is indeed an iceberg and bad at expressing himself, but why demean MC's reputation and their relationship of 5 years and MC's accident also becomes their (ML and his friend/social circle) party discussion is something that I really didn't understand. Sigh (X1)
  • Now onto the second point. What ML did was unforgivable but what MC dis was just morally wrong on so many different levels. MC identified himself as the tour-guide who passed away in the accident and even went as far as to identify himself as the grandma's family (the tour-guide's grandma. She has Alzheimer's) which is just so wrong. He also took up the other person's name, identity, his likes (white roses) and ambitions (to be an actor) and completely replaced himself with the other person. It is just... unethical.
[collapse]

I'll add unto this later.
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
dCaitsith
dCaitsith rated it
March 10, 2025
Status: c168
This review contains spoiler.

Overall this novel can be divided into 3 arcs, opening arc, Qin Zhou arc, and the last arc which they mend their relationship. I actually liked the first 2 arcs, the angst was good, the story was interesting and had content. And then came the third arc, and then the MC and ML suddenly became two kindergarten kids, the plot started to stale, all they talk about were just : one was decreasing points for the other's behaviour and refusing to add points even when he enjoyed... more>> it, and the other just buys goldfish so that his wife would add points (which he still didn't in the end). That, and the gong just talks about 'doing' it every time they speak. Do they not have other dating activities other than those? And then somehow the other still chose to marry him. Where's the connection? Where's the communication? Where the plot has gone to? So yes, I decided to drop this since I don't feel like the need to read this kind of story anymore... <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
JJQRC78
JJQRC78 rated it
November 13, 2024
Status: Completed
Cliche of domineering husband pursue after ex wife. The main characters development didn’t meet my expectations. Lack luster revenge (it can’t said revenge), the separated drama were short and don’t have deep recollection.
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
beyukii
beyukii rated it
March 12, 2024
Status: Completed
It is a good wife chasing crematorium, story doesn't drag too much because it's only over 100 chapters.

I know I'm reading a wife chasing crematorium but this ML doesn't sit right with me. I can't forgive this ML after reading, I think MC should have chosen someone else. Author tried to reason MLs actions but it was not explained logically. Such a big plothole. ML never cared for MC in the beginning, we saw it very clearly. It was not tsundere act or anything. He didn't like his eyes, he... more>> was disgusted with his kiss. He always threw away foods that he cooked, always left for others when MC is sick. Never celebrated his birthday together in 5 years. Laughed when his friends mocked MC. Threw away all of MCs stuff after hearing that he is death..... and then he was like

Spoiler

"I was going to propose to you at that timeee!"

If ML really loved, was going to propose to him why did he mock him 24/7 with his friends and calling MC a plaything? Why did he tell him that they are nothing but s*x partners? Why did he said nothing when everyone was bullying and making fun of MC for 5 years ? ML not kissing, refusing to look at MCs face during the S.., always doing it from behind, not caring if he is hurt afterwards... and he suddenly says all this is because ML cared for MC so much... like WTF? Author tried to explain but it made no sense all. He bought the exact same clothes and even glasses for what? It's his favorite brand? Then why does the white moonlight wear 100% the same thing?

[collapse]

Also MCs personality is inconsistent. I know shous in this kind of novels should be extremely cheap with a doormat personality. But this shous change is so drastic that it's unbelievable. Someone cheap like that doesn't suddenly turn into someone with shiny backbone. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Kuromi.Soldier
Kuromi.Soldier rated it
December 9, 2023
Status: Completed
The slow burn is SLOW BURNING !!!

In the first few chapters I cried ocean of tears. The ML really got a redemption arc and suffered. Though, it was already too late for him. I don't like slowburn though, I understand the MC and I stand by him.

... more>>
Spoiler

The MC confuses me sometimes. I was left wondering what's his purpose for pretending to be someone else towards ML and ML's cousin. He kept going back and forth between pretending and also not pretending. He's quite indecisive and unnecessarily sensitive too.

As for the ML, he's just a straight scum. He deserves for what's coming. Applaud to MC for not caving in. ML *only* realised his feelings *after* MC's death...

I feel bad for ML but then I remembered that he was negligent towards MC's feelings and also he's still friends with those bozos who talked sh*t about MC 🙄

ML's friends are scums to MC. ML is very aware of this. He's still in contact with them even after wanting to pursue MC. Negative points for ML.

[collapse]

Things could've been solved QUICK if they would just be honest to each other and if they know how to express their emotions properly.

My impatience is not fit to read this novel. Recommended to those who have great patience!

♥︎ I read the manhwa and only then did I realise how good the novel is because the manhwa somehow butchered the angst that's represented in the novel and turn the manhwa into a "light-angst + little bit funny" manhwa...

As for the white moonlight, the plot just doesn't execute it well enough. It's pretty out of the blue. It doesn't make sense how you'd like someone after so many years had passed by and that you *barely* saw the person when you were away. The crush is pitiful and make it seems like he is pathetic and desperate. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Jwel
Jwel rated it
July 2, 2023
Status: Completed
This novel made me cry. Although there are loop holes in the story I would give it 4stars cause I like the grief ML experienced.

I totally like the cousin. I was hoping that MC would be with him instead but sigh... they just treat each other as relatives..
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Adriana28
Adriana28 rated it
May 17, 2023
Status: c73
ok till now I actually really loved it, be it the angst or the plotline.

I loved it very much, I liked both MC and the ml. I actually don't blame ML for being so indifferent to MC, 'cause their relationship was never defined much they were just bed partners living together, so ML was not obliged to be sincere and responsible of MC but yup their were few scenes which I found extremely uncomfortable, the way he completely ignored MC after that shen guy came back without giving... more>> any explanations, giving order to throw the wontons made by MC and many more.

But the most uncomfortable thing was the way he reacted ok MC's death, his indifference and lack of care yes it could linked he had some past emotional trauma problem after his mother's death but still I found it very unbearable.

I think before MC was just way too much into ml, and ge thought he could warm the iceberg.

BUT ALWAYS REMEMBER GUYS NEVER EVER MAKE A SIMILAR CHOICE IN UR LIFE CAUSE U CAN'T CHANGE A PERSON'S ACTUALLY PERSONALITY AND IN THE END U MIGHT END UP HURTING YOURSELF.

I was looking for raws for further chapters but then I skimmed through the comments and read how horrible the story line is after 70s, so I guess I might be quitting it for now.

May be in future I would read it but till then it's a break.

Anyway thanku author and translators for ur hard work. <<less
2 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.