I see this Female MC way too young and naive which led her unable to make a firm decision.

Though it is much better if the author didn't write the last arc where the MC and her four husbands went to her modern world because the author leaves an unsatisfactory ending. I felt the author write it in a rush.

Despite saying I enjoyed reading it, the story still made me feel bitter especially since her children were left in the beast world and Curtis seems to be giving off a melancholy aura at the ending. As for why I'm not gonna tell you. It's better to read for you to know. : (

eg: she only remembers that she's futile in the middle of her menstrual cycle a few hundred chapters into the story...

she only remembers that she knows how to get salt out of sea water once again a few hundred chapters in after they lose their trading supplies

She'll end up with them all. She'll marry Curtis in modern world first (since she said she'll marry whoever will give her a female baby first) then after a couple of years, they'll move out of China to France and she'll marry Parker there and so on since it isn't specifically detailed what happened after that (It was mentioned that she marry one of them alternately after they moved out from place to place to avoid conflict and biasthey have a polygamous family in one of a poorly developed country). They just ran out of green crystal so they also eventually died but they all lived happily and longer than normal. Then there comes Lan Ze/Blue pool and Bai Anan's arc which I hope would also be translated officially

e.g. I like you because you're my partner. And then ML was happy.

e.g. Don't leave because you're my partner. And then ML was happy.

.... Seriously?

e.g. Fcking during locust plague while everyone busy killing the bugs. Some beastmen cubs even died from it. 🤦🏻‍♀️

It's more difficult for her to accept the concept of multiple husbands than pooping non-human animals out of human body or having litters who would want to mate with her in the future and the father is ready to kill them. After learning the truth, she is not shocked, not disgusted, not depressed. They went straight to make another batch of snake babies. 🤯

She called her daughter ugly when she was just born. But she felt mellow motherly love or mother-son bonding toward her animal litters soon as they're born.

She brought her baby girl to the desert, a location full of female-hater beastmen. Multiple times, she ignored the baby's safety over her partners.

The leopard cubs were often neglected. They let someone else taking care of them but sometimes the leopard cubs just fed themselves. This so called docile mother also likes kicking them... Oh, I almost forget to mention they let the cubs saw the mother having s*x with the snake.

Smh

I wouldn't say the FL is s*upid, I'd say her brain has never even existed to begin with. But well I kinda pity her. If I had to marry 4 people & had more than 10 kids by the time I reached 18 I would've killed myself. But she's too s*upid so yeah no pity for garbage

The snake dude is too possessive for my taste. Dude you guys are literally sharing

the girl calm down a little. Plus you're +40 at the start of the story. Have you no shame falling for a girl whom could -age wise- be your daughter?

The leopard one is like a spoiled & idiot child. Honey stop picking fights with someone you know you cannot beat in a hundred years. How sh*t for brain can you be?

The bird one is a rapist & obsessed dude, rivalling for the s*upid possessive cup with the snake one. Sigh

The tiger one is my favorite actually. The only person who can use like 10% of his brain. It was a pity how he r*ped her. Tho every last one if her mates has r*ped her at least once... So no biggie ig? :)

In this novel, most of the MLs just forces or straight up r*pes FL. And FL gives birth to an astronomical number of children with different MLs. In the latter part of the novel, there is a chapter where FL mates with her son and gives birth to his cubs. The daughters of FL are treated as straight up breeding machines. Like wtf! FL is both cunning and a pushover.

She uses the MLs who are caring towards her and doesn't cares about much who are just kind to her. She only mates who are forceful or give birth to their children.

Mating with so many men and giving birth to so many children are treated as a trivial thing, like eating snacks or something.

BQQ transmigrates to Bestman World, freaked out and supposely only wants one mate but ends up getting four mega strong mates lol (Cortis/Curtis, Parker, Vincent/Winston, Moore/Muir) stuff happens... tribe/village/city building... weak (?) to strong... then BQQ suddenly transmigrated back to modern world and new arc starts... we fwoosh suppons her four spouses and they live happily (?.... the last arc of An'An and Bluepool.... heartbreak! I only got to read until ch. 1652 with the eng tl and had to mtl the rest... but still.... bittersweet? end.. but it's okay.. it was like an extra... the main story is quite satisfying

To explain: Bai Qingqing is just 16 when she's thrown into the beastmen's world. She's immature, naive, and, yes, annoying. But it makes sense. Teenagers, especially when thrust into a strange, possibly traumatic situation—like waking up in a world full of people who can transform into animals—aren't paragons of maturity. Even adults would struggle in that scenario. And while I'd like to think I was more mature at 16, it's understandable that not everyone would react with grace or poise. We cannot fault her for being how she is; just like there are mature children/teens, there are also immature children/teens. Hell, some adults in our natural world remain as childish as they were in their teens. But my point is that I believe Bai's immaturity and childishness stem naturally from her age.

However, as the story continues, our main character does not mature. Initially (like most readers), I found this to be so annoying. I mean, how often will she cause trouble to others or act in ways that are sometimes downright offensive to the beast men's culture before she gets a grip and starts taking actual responsibility for her actions instead of letting her mates take care of everything? But like before, the more I thought about it, the more it made sense.

Bai Qingqing was in the beast's world for five years, and in those five years, she did not change. Why? Because her mates and the culture of the world she was in did not let her. In this world, women are so rare, making them so valuable. It is explained to us over and over again that due to their rarity, the women in this world are spoiled rotten, catered to their every whim, and allowed to do almost anything without facing any repercussions. The women in this world are not given any responsibility except the general expectation that they need to give birth to children (only give birth because I am sure that if a female beast-man did not want to raise her kids, her mates would gladly do it for her without seeing anything wrong with it). This expectation isn't even strictly adhered to since this world has an abortion-inducing medicinal broth that appears to be taken quite regularly (it must be for Parker to suggest it so early on in the story). And because of that, the women in the beast men's world grow up to be spoiled, selfish, and sometimes cruel people. While the author paints that as a bad thing and uses it to paint our protagonist in a much better light (pick-me girl much?), it once again makes sense. It makes sense for these women to act this way; it's the natural result of growing up spoiled. Can we even blame them or hold them accountable if their culture is what propagates this very behavior? It's almost like they were never allowed to mature and become friendly or good people. The friendly females we meet are probably because they were just born with a more meek and agreeable personality (it's pure luck). The women who are mean and cruel are never even given the chance of redemption because how the hell are they going to learn the value of respect, kindness, humility, and generosity when all they know is that they are valued and that they can do whatever they want? It's pretty sad if you think about it (who knows, maybe Rosa could have been a good person given the right environment).

So why does Bai remain childish and immature even five years later? Because she was never allowed to grow and mature. Her mates spoil her rotten and do not see anything wrong with her behavior. And can we blame them? Their entire lives, they were taught that this is how women are and behave. Bai's mates spoil her to a degree that prevents any character development, treating her behavior as normal since this is the only way they know to treat women. For them, she's extraordinary simply because she acknowledges them as more than servants or conveniences. The simplest gestures of kindness or attention from Bai win them over completely, and her "insane beauty" only heightens their attachment. I almost feel bad for them for expecting so little, but once again, it makes sense.

If Bai had remained in the ordinary human world for those five years, she would have slowly but surely acquired more responsibility (as we all do when we grow up) and (more importantly) been held accountable for her actions. She would have been in situations (either with friends, family, school, maybe a significant other, or even a job) where her actions would have consequences (either good or bad), and she would have had to face those consequences and be responsible for her actions. These experiences would have allowed her to mature in her way of thinking; she would have grown up. But because she has been trapped in the beast man's world where every whim and desire was catered to, where she will not be held responsible for anything she does (The whole situation with her being kicked out of the best man's city because they believed her to bring about a great catastrophe doesn't count cause everyone was driven by superstition, and this was a rare moment where Bai was innocent). Is it any wonder that she remained childish the whole time? Coming to this world may have been detrimental to whatever growth she had begun to acquire before coming to this world as a young teen; it may have set her back to an even more immature mentality.

When looking at Bai Qingqing through these lenses, her character goes from being an annoying, spoiled girl who doesn't consider the long-term impact of her choices to a tragic girl who was never allowed to grow up (until she returns to the human world and even then her mates follow her so her chances of maturity are once again stunted).

I want to mention Several scenes that illustrate Bai's dependence and immaturity.

1. When Bai returns to the human world, her mates are left in the beast men's world. She becomes so distraught at the idea that she might have to live her life without the men who have taken care of her in every sense of the word for the last five years that she would rather commit su*cide than face the world alone. I know that Bai also hypothesized that if she tried to kill herself, the near-death experience would bring her mates to her world. And while that did end up working, it was at most a theory, and Bai was aware of that. In the story, Bai was aware that there was a real chance that she would never see her mates again, and if that were to be the case, she would rather face death than go on without them. At first, I found this scene ridiculous. I mean, sure, she does love her mates and is distraught to be without them. But to come back to the human world after five years (and she didn't even think she would come back at all; it was pure luck) and have the first thing she does is attempt to off herself? I mean, come on, did she not miss her family? Her friends? Her world? Her old life? I could not believe it. But once again, if we think about it as extreme as it is, it makes sense. Her mates did everything for her; hell, she didn't even cut her nails anymore; that's how dependent she was on them. She's more like a toddler in her dependence than an adult. So, as extreme as it sounds, it would make sense for her to want not to go on if she was suddenly ripped away from that. How could she possibly go on without the men that gave her everything? She did not develop the level of independence or inner strength to go on after (potentially) losing a loved one. It's unfortunate, in my opinion.

2. Another scene is when Bai invents paper. Now, this scene had me fuming, so let me explain why. The story shows Bai to be a brilliant girl (now, being smart is not the same as being mature or responsible, as Bai kindly shows us). Throughout the story, she remembers how to make simple inventions that significantly improve life for the beastmen. She somewhat remembers how to forge metal and accidentally ushered in the beast men's equivalent of the bronze age; that is a HUGE deal. The beastmen are now forging weapons and armor. But it's the paper scene that highlights how immature Bai is. Bai remembers the process of inventing paper and introduces paper to the beastmen world. Again, she remembers how to make paper; I don't know anyone who casually remembers to make paper from scratch. Now, why is this a big deal? Because with the invention of paper comes the invention of writing. The ability to write was a GAME-CHANGER in our world. Think about it: having, preserving, and passing records down to future generations is a cultural advantage. We can write down rules, laws, and scientific discoveries and communicate with people by transporting those records. If Bai had introduced writing to the beast men, their society would have been shifted forever. Writing is transformative—it's how civilizations preserve knowledge across generations. In the story, we learn pretty early on that Curtis' (snake) species can inherit the memories of their ancestors (males, at least). Biologically speaking, that puts him at a considerable advantage. We even see Curtis use this ability several times to save himself (like when he encased himself in amber? To save himself from the fire Muir started). But only snakes have this ability. Had Bai introduced writing to the beastmen, this would have been their equivalent of that (kind of). Sure, they won't have access to direct memories from their ancestors like Curtis does. Still, they would have a method to communicate across distance and time, making the biological playing field more equal. So what does Bai do with this enormous milestone? She uses it to draw. That's it. She could have advanced this civilization but did not; she used newly invented paper to draw. It genuinely frustrated me to no end. But once again, Bai is an immature 16 year old child (mentally at least) of course she would not think about the ramifications that her inventions could bring or the long-term prosperity the beastment could enjoy, she only wants paper because she feels like drawing. This scene frustrated me, as it highlighted her limited perspective. Bai is clever but immature, thinking only of the immediate satisfaction of drawing rather than the profound potential of her invention

3. I also wanted to mention this final scene because even though it is brief, it was absolutely hilarious. The novel has a scene where Bai and her mates are eating dinner. I'm unsure if Muir was her mate at this point, but I believe he was there. Anyway, everyone is eating, and Winston is feeding his daughter. Parker (I believe it was Parker) turns to Bai and holds up a spoonful of food to feed her. Bai has this moment of clarity when she thinks, "Parker is feeding me the same way Winston is feeding An'an. How am I any different than my toddler?" When I tell you, I laugh for about a solid 10 minutes. For just a second, our dear protagonist was self-aware. God, I wish the author would have done something with this scene, but it was a small nugget of gold in the endless muddy river that is this story.

So, is Bai Qingqing an immature, childish character? Yes, but in a way that's consistent with her circumstances. Was this depth intentional? If so, it's an impressive example of nuanced characterization, and I applaud the writer. If not, then it's a case of accidental complexity that somehow elevates the story.

Of course, I have other critiques: the world-building could be more nuanced, the side characters and male leads could be better developed, and Bai's human inventions could be explored for their impact on beastmen society. But I chose to focus on Bai's characterization here, as her consistent immaturity and dependence struck me as both realistic, thought-provoking, and, ultimately, tragic.

I hate how people are hating parker the more and more for being annoying and childish like don't you people know he is f*ckin 17-18 years old even though according to beast world he is considered adult he's still not fully matured but as the time went he changed a lot and still little childish and clingy but remember this nature of him is the only reason Bai is able to be with Curtis a feral beast on top of that a snake that Bai is most afraid of. parker is also a loving father to his cubs and anan winston's daughter and snaklet of Curtis even though he hate Curtis.

It's would be so good if she ends up with all males including Curtis, parker, winston, muir, Alva, lanze and Mitchel thats why I was here for a true reverse harem even though it still is. what didn't likes is modern world arc like seriously?I was here for tribal beast world life romance in first place but modern world ruined everything not to mention lanze/bluepool and Bai anan's last arc😭. as much as I like this story especially beast world setting one I hate qingqing too cause she's so dumb. she never even considered or thought that she just transported to other world suddenly on middle of road and you don't even know how yet you never considered that what if you suddenly got transported back to your world again in middle of doing something or maybe to other completely different world. as the toxic readers know this is beastmen romance with beast tag too so what do you expect for ML's to do?act human?have candlelight dinner?purpose with diamond ring in front of people?get married?have one or two children and live happily ever after?

For God sake they are beasts even though they can transform into human form but still they are born beasts, animals mating and having children is their instinct and yeah they don't love her only for this at first it was all cause of her beauty that they fell in love with and I can understand cause beautiful females are rare. and yes male birth rate is higher than female birth rate and it is worse in merfolk clan since Theres only one female for thousands of merman and if they want new female their first female will die giving birth to a female and that's natural there so no second female along with first. there behaviour is completely normal. people who watch animal world documentaries will understand. And again yeah Bai qingqing.......... she first said she only wanted one partner than got second one then she said she only want two partners but she got third one then again she said she is happy with three of them and there's no need for fourth one then she got fourth one like girl if you don't know what happen in future just shut up. she literally says she love all of them equally but spend most of her time with Curtis who give her kiss then get h**ny and have s*x and have eggs but when parker asks she says shut up get me cloths, food, warm water go hunting etc so basically people who force her will get chance but people who asks permission first got no f*ckin chance at all but slaving around. she is weaker than beast female who is said to be weak and fragile even though she's from modern world she is weakest compare to other manhwa fls. in modern world women is not that weak and this girl is ruining modern girls image in other world. she uses her modern knowledge just to show off like "you uneducated beasts try the food recipes I tell. do you like my ideas?then praise me I'm a modern female afterall"

She don't listen to anyone all the troubles you read in novel is caused by s*upidity. she went on loooong desert journey just to confirm if winston/Vincent is fine and take him home on top of that leaving her young cubs home alone and taking a baby only few months old to hot desert and there destination was scorpion tribe where female haters male live. it would be best if molly/jasmine were the FL she is way stronger than her and I also saw her in manhua and I think she's way beautiful and cuter than Bai even qin/jean.i don't mind if qin too were FL but qingqing sigh.

I should stop now cause the comment literally became soooooooooo looooooong