Sha Po Lang

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

“The first person to dig ziliujin fuel out of the ground could never have predicted that what they dug out was the beginning of a dog-eat-dog age.

Our entire life was but an ugly confidence game of greed; this is something everyone knows, but that they could not bring to light.

From where did this con begin? Maybe from atop the first clean white canvas sails of a foreign ship that sailed across the ocean, or from beneath the great wing of a Giant Kite as it rose unsteadily into the skies — or from a time even before that: as the spreading ziliujin, like an ink stain upon the earth, turned the great plains of the wild north into a sea of flames.

Or maybe it was when We… when I met Gu Yun in a world all covered in ice and snow.”

Associated Names
One entry per line
Shā Pò Láng
SPL
Stars of Chaos
Sát Phá Lang
Winner Is King (Drama Adaptation)
Убить Волка
Шаполан
ฆ่าหมาป่า
杀破狼
殺破狼
烽火流金 [Live Action Drama]
살파랑
Related Series
N/A
Recommendations
Golden Stage (13)
Imperfections (8)
Qiang Jin Jiu (8)
To Rule in a Turbulent World (7)
Liu Yao: The Revitalization of Fuyao Sect (7)
Those Years In Quest Of Honour Mine (5)
Recommendation Lists
  1. Top danmeis
  2. done reading: danmei novels
  3. Danmei I've Read + Rating ^_^
  4. Completed Bl
  5. My List of Shame

Latest Release

Date Group Release
06/30/22 Northwest Flower extra 16
12/26/21 SPLtrans c37
12/19/21 SPLtrans c36
12/12/21 SPLtrans c35
12/05/21 SPLtrans c34
11/28/21 SPLtrans c33
11/21/21 SPLtrans c32
11/14/21 SPLtrans c31
11/07/21 SPLtrans c30
10/31/21 SPLtrans c29
10/24/21 SPLtrans c28
10/17/21 SPLtrans c27
10/10/21 SPLtrans c26
10/03/21 SPLtrans c25
09/26/21 SPLtrans c24
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
120 Reviews sorted by


Da_An77
Da_An77 rated it
February 20, 2021
Status: Completed
Sha Po Lang may has unconventional couple start, however Priest manages to built the relationship between MC and ML so well you can help but root for their happiness. Their love grow within the chaos which surrounded their country. This turbulent time may becomes the obstacle for our leads, but it was also the main driven for them to push their limit to save their country. And to finally have a peaceful life together.
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
XianYiXi
XianYiXi rated it
January 9, 2021
Status: Completed
WARNING: This novel focus more on politics and Wars and Battles than Romance.

This is the best novel of all Priest's Novel I have Read. I have no words to described it. It hard to find such a good written novel. I really like the story building of the world, especially The War and Battles were so well written, Truly a Masterpiece.

This is my first time reading seme as protagonist (MC) and it was pretty unique and good. I really love the Relationship of MC and ML Although it... more>> Knocks on my Guilty Pleasure Point but....... who cares. Our MC (CG) kind of remind me of Luo Binghe from SVSSS in some aspect
Spoiler

They both were mixed blood.

They both liked someone much older than them.

They both have inappropriate Relationship. One with his Shizun another with his Yifu. The former one is better than the latter.

One is all about "Shizun" and other is all about "Yifu". Everytime CG calls GY "Yifu" I end up remembering LBH.

They both have something inside them that they aren't able to control. Thank god, this didn't end up like SVSSS where uke sacrifice his ass to bring Seme under Control from exploding.

[collapse]

As for ML (GY), he remind me of Wei Ying from MDZS
Spoiler

ㄟ (-᷄ ω -᷅) ㄏTheir level of shamelessness

How they can so seductive.

Good at flirting and impressing girls

They both carries flute and can use it against the enemy, although the way they use it is quite different.

And they both are so narcissist

Well, it's good that GY was not totally like WY. it's good that he found out about CG feeling pretty soon on his own, unlike my clown WY, making us wait almost until the end of the novel

[collapse]

I really love how the story was multiple dimensional. I really like how we got to know the reason for some people action.

Leaving aside the main and supporting characters and even villains, I even felt so sad for some Fodder character which appear only for a while to be killed
Spoiler

like the guy, the small soilder, who died while protecting CG in watch tower. His death was so sad. Only his arms were left. He was only 15 at that time.

[collapse]

For me the ending of a story, the way story ends matters a lot. I really love the way this novel ended. Neither rushed nor lagg. Plus the extra chapter with beautiful story (that we wanted to know) made it even more fantastic.

I really enjoyed the journey but as always in some part I really find Priest description hard to imagine. I have to read it for 2 or 3 times to fully get that scene and what's going on (especially the mecha thing) 😅😂😁.

Well, I'll miss, Cheng Geng, Gu Yun, Cao Chunhua, Ge Chen, Shen Yi and Miss Chen. It was so nice to see them all grown up and getting old. Finally, the story ended where we started from.

Atlast, As a pure Yaoi Fan, I really want to read the "the Beautiful Scene" in Bed, especially when the couple have good amd sexy relationship and great chemistry. It's sad that Priest doesn't write Smut, Although I know and can understand her but still I feel sad 😢😢😢. Once again I have to go and feed my greedy eyes, heart and soul some Fanfiction of this novel with the "beautiful Scene" <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Yaoisensei
Yaoisensei rated it
February 21, 2020
Status: c128
Phew. This is the most wordy book I've ever read (and I read the legendary master's wife). From chapter 80 I think I was just pushing through from stubbornness. I was so ecstatic when I finished the last word. That being said, the story was really good.

I loved the world building and the characters with all their quirky personalities. The romance was swoon worthy and the MC and ML had really cute and hilarious interactions. I found myself LOLing and asking "wow did he really just..." A LOT and when... more>> your guard is down from the swoon they stab you with knives and feelings.

Side characters were also very well done. in depth with their own story lines. No lie, I would suffer through more of this story for some of those side characters. I still need to read the extra chapters but aside from the wordiness this was a modern classic.⭐⭐⭐⭐

Pros to the translator and their hard work. It was pretty well done. I can't imagine how long it took to translate such a wordy book. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
bluecookie
bluecookie rated it
January 25, 2020
Status: Completed
  • Extremely good plot
  • Likeable characters
  • Well-balanced romance
I won't say anything else you should just try reading this because why? Changgu is life!!
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
hejikkk
hejikkk rated it
May 1, 2024
Status: Completed
tbh didn't really understand the hype.

very difficult to digest--- the translator did a great job but this is definitely a book to be read in its original language.

i liked the characteration of the MC and ML in the beginning of the series, but as time went on I feel that they lost their more unique qualities.

also didn't understand the romance part. In my eyes they never seemed to grow out of their foster father + son relationship, and in particiular, I couldn't distinguish any event where this change happened to... more>> gu yun.

i think it's okay for normal couples to have a more ambiguous transition, but for something in the nature of these two, I would argue that a distinct break is needed.

the enemies were also scary in the beginning but became underwhelming as time dragged on.

however, I did like how it was written as a historical fiction, and it was very interesting to search up the real life lores of certain characters. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
PhoenixRosha
PhoenixRosha rated it
January 19, 2022
Status: --
This is the best romance BL novel I have ever read 😍 Slow burn and the romance is sparsely scattered among the strong political plot. Yet you can feel the strong feelings of the main leads.

If fixing the whole damn country just so that your love can live carefree is not romantic. Then what is ??!!
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Indelible Faith
Indelible Faith rated it
December 19, 2020
Status: extra 15
Beautiful, engaging, politically and dramatically charged, dangerously complex and sweetly romantic, this has to be one of the best action-packed steampunk novels I have read!

Chang Geng is a wonderful example of a character that goes from weak to strong, and as many say "evolves like a pokemon everytime he appears". His early life has been a train ride of misery, but it hasn't diminished his capacity to care for and love people, something that we keep seeing as the story progresses.

Gu Yun on the other hand, is the steady character.... more>> The only development he gets, yet arguably the most significant, is how he slowly begins to place "self care" higher and higher on his priority list, if only to please and placate Chang Geng. But it's clear that he finally has something to live for now, and live happily too.

The plot is tight, political and the palace drama stays very firmly inside the boundaries of realism despite the whole steampunk genre. Every character here is nuanced, especially the Emperor Li Feng. Shades of grey is how I would describe the whole court!

Even the antagonists are well developed, and have victories and losses of their own. There is no easy and quick solution to the problems that arise, the MC and ML have to work and toil for every hard earned merit, and so the satisfaction of reaching the conclusion is really relieving!

But despite the war and battle and politics, there is a good amount of humor and sweet romantic scenes in the book! The relationship between Chang Geng and Gu Yun isn't rushed, but a slow build across the years.

Truly a beautiful combination of all the elements.

PS: Hats off to the translators who have done an incredible job, because the original chinese is on a literary level so high that it can only be regarded in awe!!!!

4½🌟 <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Charmian
Charmian
April 23, 2020
Status: Completed
This novel is one of the best I have ever read. I was crushed when I finnished it and I am really craving for more..

The plot's great, although I struggeled a bit with those affairs halfway through, but I connected the story as it progressed.

The romance is just.. amazing. It's a beautiful slowburn and it really felt natural and mutual between them. Precious.

Additionally, I have to point out Priest's sense of humour... My god, how I love it.

I'm really looking forward to reread this gem sometime in the future! = ̄ω ̄=
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
stardustmist
stardustmist rated it
March 4, 2020
Status: Completed
Priest definitely is my favorite author, she's just amazing and I am in short for words to describe her writing.

The story leans more on politics and sometimes I feel s*upid cause my knowledge isn't so vast. However, you can't help but fall in love with the characters. It has adventure, comedy, lots of conspiracies and a little bit of romance.

This was my first ever Priest novel and honestly, she just blew me away!!!

Protect Chang Geng and his precious Yifu!!! I really love when he calls Gu Yun, Yifu, it's just... more>> too pleasing to read haha.

Plot: 7/5 stars

Characters: 10/5 stars

Also, the flow of character and romance is just so beautiful. It isn't rushed, Gu Yun comes to love his adopted son slowly and it doesn't look or sound weird. The love between them develops naturally and oh, I just love them so much!!!

The translator did an amazing job and her notes are funny haha. Definitely worth the read!! Please give Sha Po Lang and ChangGu lots of love, Shen Yi, too~ <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
MagicalAnacardo
MagicalAnacardo rated it
December 14, 2019
Status: v4c118
This story is extremely well researched. There's a lot of focus on strategy, politics and economy in a nation dealing with war and crisis, and in the middle of that, bittersweet romance. The secondary characters are deep and lovable, which is something I really miss while reading other novels. Both main characters are imperfect, and so the author can clearly show their growth thorought the narrative until you love them to death. There's a lot of tragic and violent scenes and backgrounds, but they go hand in hand with really... more>> ridiculous and shameless scenes that have made me spit my coffee all over my laptop more than once. I'm so grateful for this translation... It's really good that the translator keeps including notes about the language and the different meanings of some words! <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
AhhPop
AhhPop rated it
June 5, 2024
Status: Completed
I'm unsure about my feelings on this. I might rate it a 4.0 because I'm somewhat biased in favor of the author and don't want to give fewer stars, especially since others might appreciate it more than I do. I wanted to closely follow the characters in every situation they were in, but while reading, it felt like watching a TV series, which made it seem like everyone was just acting. : (

At times, it felt like I was reading a historical book, which then made me fully aware that... more>> the romance parts and humor are all fictionally inserted. : ((distracting my immersion)

Anyway, all the characters are truly inspiring, especially the two main ones. My favorite character is actually the side character, Shen Yi, but everyone has a unique personality that adds depth to the novel. Despite my uncertainty about the rating, I have to admit that my heart ached after finishing the book and I longed for more. Maybe, despite knowing it's Shounen Ai, I secretly wished for more sweetness between the main characters. I understand their chemistry and have no complaints about it. The romance between these two intellectuals has a certain restraint, not because they aren't passionate about each other, but because their strong minds allow them to excel in their daily lives without being overly distracted. Thus, the novel focuses less on romance and more on resolving conflicts and showcasing how the characters' minds tackle challenges and achieve their goals.

Spoiler

Spoiler.................................................

[collapse]

People mentioned that they couldn't see their relationship as more than that of an adopted father and son, and found the romance a bit awkward. I can understand the taboo surrounding a romance that evolves from a father-son dynamic. However, the heart loves what it loves. When Gu Yun rescues Cheng Geng from the wolf, he can see a connection between Cheng Geng and his younger self. Gu Yun, having had strict parents, can't help but have different ideas on raising a child and eagerly pours all his love into Cheng Geng, subconsciously testing his ideas. Cheng Geng, who matured early due to a tough childhood, initially sees Gu Yun as his "father" and feels a need to take care of him. Tortured by his "mother, " Cheng Geng was restless and saw the world as bleak, always in survival mode. His first impression of Gu Yun was of someone naive and weak, needing to depend on others. Recognizing Gu Yun's sincere love, Cheng Geng saw himself as superior and felt a sudden sense of protection for his Yifu, developing a sense of responsibility. Their love in its purest form at this stage is "Protection and Nurturing." Regardless, Cheng Geng has already envisioned Gu Yun as someone who will stay with him. And well, Cheng Geng was only 14 when he was already aware that he was attracted to Gu Yun physically.

Later on, when Cheng Geng realized that Gu Yun was much stronger and more capable than him, he felt proud but also a bit helpless. The person he admired didn't need him to tackle any issues. Some might argue that his desire for self-improvement was driven by a moral duty to relieve his father's burden, but that's not the case. If he wanted to, Cheng Geng could have distanced himself from Gu Yun both now and in the future. Cheng Geng's dedication to his studies and self-improvement was not just for personal growth but also to stay connected with Gu Yun. Despite Cheng Geng still being able to see him occasionally if he just stayed at home, their bond grew stronger when they were both equally capable in areas they valued. They matched intellectually, with Gu Yun excelling on the frontier and Cheng Geng handling civil affairs better, making them complement each other perfectly.

Why would Gu Yun accept Cheng Geng's view of their relationship? Initially, he was suffocated by it and denied it. You could say he loves Cheng Geng regardless of what the kid thinks. Eventually, he might have just gone with the flow—since he already loves him, any kind of relationship is acceptable. Some people are dissatisfied with this and feel it wasn't a genuine romantic feeling. But how rare is it to feel that any relationship is fine as long as you can be close to and stick around this person? To me, it is pure love and genuine romance from the heart.

Near the end, the audience becomes more aware of the helplessness of human flesh on the battlefield and the inevitable aging process. This brings a sense of vulnerability, and I was a bit disappointed that the author didn't have all the characters fully acknowledge this reality. I suppose she didn't want to diminish the liveliness of the story by addressing the fear of aging and fading beauty. However, I would have appreciated it if this theme was presented, as it would have made the novel more touching. It's a fear that the audience should be able to confront and recognize with maturity.

In conclusion, I'm glad I read it. My favorite character is still Shen Yi. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Ppkk85
Ppkk85 rated it
October 26, 2021
Status: Completed
Story line is amazing! And the romance is so few but so sweet! 4 start bc the plot is full of politics! There’s literally a chapter where people were just discussing politics and I am so lost! I don’t even pay attention to real life politics hence why I am reading fantasy BL novels! I still don’t understand how CG feels about his emperor brother.
Spoiler

So did CG really wanted the emperor to die? Did he help aid the emperor’s death?

[collapse]
Overall, still a good read.
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
k540
k540 rated it
October 10, 2021
Status: Completed
First: You should read this novel. (Use the translation by northwest flower. Net)

Second: It is true, what other reviews have said, that the romance is not as front and center as other danmei that I have read (though it is still an integral part of the MC and ML's characters and the development of the novel). HOWEVER, it is just as satisfying (or even more satisfying) than the others. Why? Because the affection between the MC and ML is equal and they are not afraid to express it! I... more>> find that there is an annoying trend in many novels that start out with a one sided love, that once they get together, one of the couple has to be coerced or tricked or annoyed into showing affection for the other. However, not in Sha Po Lang. Here both the MC and ML are not reluctant to let the other know their feelings and to act on them. They both love each other. They both want each other. They would both die for the other. Though the MC has a bit of an obsession and is clingy sometimes (because of some s*** he's been through), the ML understands that and instead of always getting annoyed with him and pushing him away, he accepts him and tries to fulfill his needs. So, though the sweet and fluffy moments are fewer, they are unbearably sweet and reflect a realistic couple where both people are truly in love.

Third: This would be an excellent book even if there was zero romance. I find that in other danmei, people tend to want the romance so much because the other plot points in the book lose their interest. However, in Sha Po Lang, the plot is complex and not at all boring. The development of the MC through the pilot is interesting in and of it self. That said, the romance still does drive some of the plot, it is just a bit more subtle. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
BlackLoveInSpace
BlackLoveInSpace rated it
September 23, 2021
Status: Completed
This is honestly Priest's best work.

Characters

Although Chang Geng is the main character, it is Gu Yun who steals the spotlights and our hearts. Seriously, I felt like falling for him with every page, at the same time as our MC.

Chang Geng is introverted and sensitive, with a slight general distaste for other people. Gu Yun is charming and ironic, avoiding sincerity and attachment. Chang Geng loves his Gu Yun, and he learns how to love his country. Gu Yun loves his country, and he learns how to love... more>> his Chang Geng.

Devoid of love from a young age, Gu Yun finds himself forced to adopt a brat. He now has to give him the childhood he's never had the luxury to live. With a hateful mother and no desire to live on, Chang Geng finds solace in spending time with his unexperienced adoptive father.

Their relationship is overwhelming with love, not the romantic type, but rather a quiet attachment. It only goes further after they become similar in mindset and social status, which is a very mature and realistic approach. Chang Geng has to first grow up and prove himself to the world.

Spoiler

They also have a fight at some point that you don't often see in danmei, and it is- satisfying? There is love even in the way they argue, they know each other's weak points and never ever attack there. Gu Yun always pushes Chang Geng, who is significantly younger, to be a better person and value himself more. Even as equals, (and even him being the- well- the uke) he never stops being a father figure.

[collapse]

Was this again a novel about war and politics? :O Their relationship makes about 20% of the plot but to me it was the most memorable part.

Plot

The plot is awesome with creating and releasing tension. One of out characters holds political power, the other has the military authority. Take a sip whenever Chang Geng charms another official with his diplomacy and wit, or when Gu Yun barely escapes death.

Throught the story, his body gradually deteriorates even further. Gu Yun is battle-worn, is spine is a mess, his back covered in scars, on top of having weakened senses, yet he has no choice but to go on. Nobody else is qualified to lead the elite. Bot him and the audience know he is going to fall in battle sooner or later, there is no hope for retirement in such a profession.

This makes the reader realize how we are not valuable as individuals, even the commander is just a peon in the grand scheme of things. His fate was sealed the moment he was born into that family.

The last few chapters are just perfect, there is so much tension at that point that is just stressful to read, even one year later it still gives me chills when I think of them.

On the political side, I wasn't that invested but I can't deny that if you like the subject and can memorize the names of like 20 officials it can be quite intriguing.

The descriptions of war are also on point; empathizing both the awesomeness and romanticized blood-pumping battles and the traumatic and hopeless experiences of the characters going through them.

Extra chapters/ Epilogue

I sometimes skip the extra chapters but they are incredibly important in this story. They basically continue it from whence it was left and also detail past events we've only heard of.

Epilogue spoilers!
Spoiler

I can't help but love how wholesome it goes in the end. They grow old together but Gu Yun stays as beautiful as ever, just how he wished, even as his hair begins to grow silver. They both let go of some habits that upset the other, making a mutual and wordless understanding.

[collapse]

TL;DR: I love Gu Yun

In short, I absolutely love this story and I really hope it will get an official english printed version someday.

Go read the novel! <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Ilovelovescene
Ilovelovescene rated it
July 19, 2021
Status: Completed
8.5/10

this is a 'Just finish it this morning and couldn't stop thinking about it and really want to reread already' review.

Like many people say this is a War Story. About long rotten country and how the heroes are struggle to cure it. the romance is one of the best romance I've read this year. the leads characters development are amazing. The side people are interesting but the writer keep push them back in the background. I just want all of them in the room together they are allllll fun. Priest... more>> give us some juice in the extras tho. soooo good

the story are simpler than you think. Priest just seem so passionate in telling it that it scare off people. she detailed it like her life depend on it. I FEEL it. kind of amazing.

the writing style is master. it just don't hurt my ADHD brain while read and re-read line. so clear and thought out. step by step. like river. like it's alive and living, go really well with the story.

BUT the story is not without flaws. the major flaw is the lacking of good villain. make the build up tension hang mid air.

this is my first Priest Novel. let's say I'm a little disappoint in the plot department but very in love with the world building and its characters.

Read this if.....

-you interest in reading so many 'detailed' war strategy. Politics. Priest challenge you to catch up time and time again. leave things unsaid, ETC. she seem to enjoy writing very much.

-you don't mind adoptive father/son relationship. it was a major part of the story. don't force yourself

-you like reading about "super smart characters". it was very common in Asian lit. we think smart people are hot AF LOL. still they are far from perfect.

-Many funny shits happen. Gu Yun is leading the comedy here. All Support Characters are fun and entertaining

I find it very strange for people to feel uneasy about the love line when reading this. because at the very beginning Chang Geng never really regard Gu Yun as his father at all. And Gu Yun never really act like father figure. And it was very common for kids to developed crush in Chang Geng age.

More than that they're pretty much fcked up people who find hope in each other. they thought they will never have anybody as their own then they got each other. reading them carefully dance into each other is the best experience so far.

*Spoiler ahead**** thing I don't like

Spoiler

the thing that I don't really like it Book3. We got the war build up for 2 big ass books. We got the chilling war, the devastating state, I got goosebumps at some point.

but the following inner struggle court politics is very weak.

it wad okay if Priest want to spotlight on how smart Yan Wang is. I know Priest want to show us the Reform giant plot.

But to make someone smart they need to win real threat. here we got many easily solve politics. make one think that if the bad nobles are this s*upid why didn't they fall on their skirt faster?

i don't know... It fun to read but couldn't help feel boring to read similar situations through out the book. At last it does pick up a bit at the end of book3

[collapse]

so that why I give it 8.5 <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Moon1111
Moon1111 rated it
June 8, 2021
Status: Completed
This is my first Priest book and I can see why she is so popular. I would have never thought I would be rooting for characters who started off as a father and son type of relationship and then evolved into a story that left a deep impression on me. I wish I could draw people well or sing well so that I could make a love dedication haha. Maybe Ill write a poem!

I am new to the world of Chinese novels and somehow wishing I could read Chinese so... more>> that I could fully appreciate all the nuances of Priest's work. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Shrike1978
Shrike1978 rated it
May 13, 2021
Status: Completed
I have to start by saying, I gave this story five stars DESPITE a translation that made my teeth hurt. Too much pinyin, too many unexplained idiomatic sayings (footnotes! Please!) grammar problems. Ugh. If you're willing to slog through the problems created by the translator, the story is worth it. This was based on the older translation of Sha Po Lang. Not the SPL Trans version. TOTALLY a five star story.

I also want to address some people's insistence that Golden Stage is a second rate rip off of Sha... more>> Po Lang. Yes, they both have characters who are generals. They have characters who are disabled/ill. They are set in an alternate ancient China. But if that made them the same then just about every interstellar transmigration story would be a rip off of each other. She Po Lang is DIFFERENT. The steampunk magic, external threats, illnesses that are curses. Different types of characters. The emperor's character. The underground masters helping MC. The main point is: you don't have to tear one story down to build up the other! Both can be good.

Okay, rant over. This was a very dense, intense amazing story. Loved the steampunk/ancient China combination. I thought the characters of the MC and ML were very interesting and different than so many you see. The side characters had nuances, the author even gave some development to one of the bad guys who could easily work as a cardboard cutout. I didn't have any problem following the web of plots even with the translation quality. I was very impressed with this author and hope that a better translation shows up. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
CariadWinter
CariadWinter rated it
May 6, 2021
Status: Completed
Let me start by saying that I enjoyed this novel. I won't say that it is the best story I have ever read, but it was very well written and it kept me interested from start to finish.

I loved the world that Priest created. It was vivid and bright, even during the dark times. I live for steampunk and was so very excited when I discovered Sha Po Lang! There have been comments about aspects of the steampunk world feeling disconnected or hard to visualize, but I had no trouble... more>> with it at all.

Spoiler

In fact, one of my favorite scenes is that first New Years celebration in the capital. The city in lights, the red kites, the crowds, the colorful descriptions, the atmosphere. It was all brilliant. So perfectly executed.

[collapse]

The story itself was excellent. From start to finish, there were little to no weak points, save for the ending - which I will talk about in a moment. However, I enjoyed the conflicts that arose, most of the battles were well thought out and executed, and each piece tied in well with the next. The politics, the war & military aspects, the hardships of the civilians, and yes, the bit of romance thrown in here and there. It was all very well written.

As for the characters, sadly, I found that I simply could not emotionally attach myself to most of them. At least not beyond Gu Yun and Chang Geng - and to a lesser extent Shen Yi.

I both loved and hated the dynamic between Gu Yun and Chang Geng. I understood, overall, why both of them were the way they were. I felt for both of them. I loved both of them. And, at times, I wanted to shake both of them.
Spoiler

Did the adoptive father\adopted son relationship give me issues? No. Well, not after the time jump at any rate. Once Chang Geng was older I was good. They spent so much time apart that - short of the yifu kink sprinkled in here and there - their relationship always felt lightyears away from an actual father/son relationship.

My favorite moments between them came from the added extras. Those scenes hit the hardest and made me feel the most. Especially Chang Geng's response to Gu Yun's letter. My heart ached for him. For both of them honestly because Gu Yun's reaction through the whole scene was pure gold. It was honest and raw and it made me hurt for him.

However, the line in the book when Chang Geng said he could no longer tell what was a lie and what was truth when it came from Gu Yun - I felt that. Every time Gu Yun lied to him, or kept the truth from him, I hurt. I understood Gu Yun's reasoning. I really did. But when you've told so many lies to the person you care about that they can no longer decipher real from fake - that's not healthy. That's not okay. And that Chang Geng simply went along with it because he knew in his heart that the man loved him, I can't say that was especially healthy either. But they both had their flaws. Chang Geng told his own lies and held back his own truths. Though never, I feel, to the extent that Gu Yun did. There's saving face and wanting to appear indestructible, and then there's simply not trusting your lover enough to know that they can take hearing the truth. Chang Geng, I think, in my heart, could have weathered more than Gu Yun believed he could. But I understand why Gu Yun felt he couldn't. Felt that neither of them could. And it breaks my heart a little.

[collapse]

On a lighter note, Shen Yi, bless him, was simply my source of endless amusement. I felt his pain and frustration. This man was tormented so much. Gods I just wanted to hug him.

The other characters seemed to simply drift in and out of the story with no real impact. Yes, they were there. Yes, they mattered. Yes, they had impacts on the story in their own ways. But I found that, overall, I did not care whether they lived or died. Even the villains didn't evoke any sort of strong emotion from me - except Hu Ge Er. She conjured up many emotions for me and none of them were good.

With the others, I grew frustrated from time to time with some, giggled here and there over others, but beyond that, there was nothing. This I found sad because I wanted to love the characters. I want to care about them, but largely didn't.

The ending, as well, was another sad point for me. There was no 'UMPH'. The final battles felt more perfunctory. It tied everything up and was done. Said, 'hey, here's an ending'. Scenes with certain characters that should have delivered a powerful 'punch' merely fizzled and flickered out with a pitiful whimper and a feeling of resignation. A feeling of 'Oh... this is it. Well okay then.'

Overall:

Would I read this again? Yes

Would I recommend this to someone? Yes. Read it. Read it now. You need to. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Justan_apple
Justan_apple rated it
May 3, 2020
Status: Completed
There're a number of things I love about this book but it could be quite hard to read for many people so here's a heads-up.

Priest's literary style is quite flowery, laced with many Chinese idioms, metaphors and reference so it may seem wordy when being translated into english. Spl is extremely plot-heavy with lots of politic schemes and wars; the romance only takes about 1/4 (or even less) of the book so if you skim through all the politics and are just here for the romance, I wouldn't recommend this... more>> books. It's a plot-focused book with a side of romance, not the other way around.

Even the plot itself is very slow burn, you may feel very bored around chapter 30 (tbh the first time I read spl, I also had to take a break around this part and came back to it later when I had the mood), but please remember, the MC was only around 14 at the beginning, he needed time to grow; plus those chapters were setting-up for the war ahead as it is the EXPLANATION for the downfall of the country. Once it reaches the war arc, everything gets intense real fast and you feel like you have to keep your breath through the whole chapters. The characters are all very unique; they were portrayed with depth and reasons and their development is just superb.

Moving to the romance, although there were not much intimate scenes, it was still written very satisfyingly. You may wonder how the author will transform the love of a father and a son into the love between partners but worry not, it was dealt with very intricately.
Spoiler

Basically there was no father-son love at the beginning. ML has never known what the love of a father was like and consequently didn't know how to be a father either. He raised MC just the same way his father did to him: let him do whatever he wants and doesn't interfere with anything. ML's love for MC since the beginning has always been guarding and protection for the weaker and has nothing to do with the father-son love, thus, created a room for the romantic love to develop. As for the MC, he never loved the ML like a father/parent. He actually had a crush on him since they first met, even.

[collapse]
Are they in*est? No, they are distant cousins, like at least 3 generations of distance and that is even legal nowadays. However, there is a 7-8 age difference. Just like the plot, the loveline is very slow burn but very real and logical.

Overall, please don't be put off by everything I have said and give it a try, you definitely won't regret it by the end. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Rena877
Rena877 rated it
April 18, 2020
Status: Completed
This is F*CKING AMAZING!

This plot is a masterpiece: by having a smart MC and ML the complexity of this novel is high. The storyline presents exceptionally thorough war strategies, politics, economics and schemes (parties plotting against each other, rebellion etc.). The interaction between the MC|ML starts off in the childhood days of the MC and takes the reader through his adolescence, 4 years of separations and then the "restart" of their relationship. It's a very very slow romance without smut or cheesy scenes: it still contains sweet and fluffy moments... more>> without sacrificing the MANLY character traits, staying realistic and true to the respective personalities.

The main focus of this novel is clearly the plot, romance only secondary, explicit scenes non existent.

As plot-twists are everywhere, you have absolutely no clue what the grand plan of MC actually is, which keeps the tension constantly built up. Meanwhile ML's easy going character grants superb comedic moments in between. Very well balanced. Due to the heavy and detailed plot this certainly is no skim-through material, but the translation is very well made, so you can read through this smoothly. [Sometimes the grammar is a little off, though almost undetectable]

And I love the fact that this one of the few BLs that actually has a likeable, capable female character. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.