MC decides to leave ML for like 4 years to "protect" him from other guy who loves her—he threatened to make trouble for ML but she could have atleast said a word to ML instead of asking him to pick a ton of flowers for her and dipping

I never like to write a bad review. I think this is my first time writing one for a novel. Everything was okay until ex husband come and 'threatened' the MC with ML and then she decided to 'sacrifice' herself then and there and leave ML to go with ex-husband. What the?!! What was your purpose to find ML at the beginning, isn't it to live with him happily ever after. Why suddenly turn into sacrificing self for the world kind of story. Can't you hold your principle? Acting like this I almost think that MC wants to go back with her ex-husband and acting like a victim. All the things that can be solved by communicating and trust each other but no, she decided to be a martyr. Really if I was the ML, no need to chase, lots of fish in the sea. If it's not 17 chapter before the end, I would have stop reading and be done with it. This kind of vibe makes me hesitate to read BG story. At the end, didn't manage to finish this

The fact this is all a self fulfilling time loop was both really cool and also made me a little sad. Our MC experienced two complete lives. Our ML experienced one complete life and than when he time looped he skipped a good 10 years. Felt like their was a version of him who never got to know happiness. That in no way diminished from how lovely this story was.

I love how the s*um ex here is not given a chance, it's not that he's irredeemable but if the FL after her first life gave him another chance I'd be questioning her sanity and drop this.

Its just pure love between them, through thick and thin, rich or poor.

Each others future lies in each others past.

MC's 2nd life was in ML's 1st life while ML's 2nd life was in MC's 1st. So cool.

The ex husband, no matter how I look at it. Is a big freakin s*umbag.

In their 1st life he took MC for granted because she loved him so so much. All kinds of pain was experience by MC its just heartbreaking. But still guilt trip MC while their divorce is ongoing and at the end of the divorce too.

In their rebirth aka 2nd life of MC amd Ex Husband (1st Life of ML) he had the guts to look for MC and made MC leave ML for 3 yrs. He just pisses me off that I really want to punch him in the face.

The first is the former student of the ML's "teacher". This guy is a rapist who targeted one village girl and the ML's older sister (as well as students when he went to be an assistant professor) as well as stole funds and blamed it on the ML's teacher. He attempts to divert attention from himself to the ML by revealing the pig farm the ML was running during the time this was considered bad. Between the witnesses (and victims) of his various r*pes, proof that he stole the money (and then tried to frame someone else twice for it), and the involvement of the MC's ex from the previous life, he is sentenced to death.

The other is the MC's ex from her previous life. He is also a regressor and remembers the life he had with the MC. He desperately wants to renew his romance with her and make up to her about what happened (such as the miscarriage of their two children) but the MC has moved on. So he forces her to leave the ML but in the end, she still doesn't open her heart to him and they go their separate ways. Or at least I'm assuming because once the MC and ML reunite, he is only briefly mentioned in passing with no closure on that arc at all. I know that this was done so the ML can become a powerful businessman but it was still weird.

Despite the fact that this woman has been constantly described as being confined to a bed for most of the story, she gets a wheelchair and eventually becomes a math/science professor at university. They even describe her hair as 'thinning' to indicate she's getting older and weaker but she's given a paragraph about how she is now a professor.

I admit that he is not the worst s*um in the world or anything like that, but no matter the reason or upbringing, I just feel like it's unrealistic for him to say that he is in love with MC.

For 16 years, he said that he didn't love her but there is familial affection, but for me, this is wrong. He just didn't pay didn't give a sh*t, only after MC become depressed then he the missing part. If MC keeps acting like everything is fine, he will still treat her like shit. In the end, it's all about him, so I disagree about him getting a third chance or about him not at fault. Clearly it's obvious that he didn't even treat her decently for 16 years, so he better stay away from MC or anyone for that matter if that's how he's like.