The Husky and His White Cat Shizun

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

Mo Ran thought becoming Chu Wanning’s disciple was a mistake.

His shizun was really too much like a cat while he himself was a dumb pup who’d only slobber and wag his tail.

Dogs and cats were different by nature; originally, the dumb pup didn’t want to reach his furry paws out to that cat.

At first he thought, dogs should be with dogs, like his shixiong, beautiful and tame like a cute Japanese Spitz, and the two of them together would surely be a match made in heaven.

Yet, after having died and reborn, after having lived two lives, the one he hauled back each time to his den in the end was always the one he couldn’t stand at first: that snow-white kitty shizun.

Associated Names
One entry per line
2ha
Erha
Husky Và Sư Tôn Mèo Trắng Của Hắn
Immortality (Drama Adaption)
Èr hā hé tā de bái māo shī zūn
Хаски и Его Учитель Белый Кот
Хаскі та його Вчитель Білий Кіт
ฮัสกี้หน้าโง่กับอาจารย์เหมียวขาวของเขา
ဟက်စကီနှင့် သူ၏ ကြောင်ဖြူ ဆရာသခင်
二哈和他的白猫师尊
二哈和他的白貓師尊
海棠微雨共归途
이합화타적백묘사존: 바보 허스키와 그의 흰 고양이 사존
Related Series
Yu Wu (Shared Universe)
Recommendations
The Scum Villain’s Self-Saving System (14)
Wu Chang Jie (11)
The Founder of Diabolism (10)
Heaven Official’s Blessing (7)
Every Day the Protagonist Wants to Capture Me (6)
The Reader and Protagonist Definitely Have to Be in True Love (6)
Recommendation Lists
  1. Historical danmei
  2. Promising TBRs huhuhu
  3. Series I'd shove at people's faces if they asked m...
  4. Older Shou, Uke, Bottom. Younger Gong, Seme, Top r...
  5. Big/manly bttm
Books (#ad)

Latest Release

Date Group Release
04/27/23 Treasure Chest Subs c51
09/09/22 Aiimee c50
09/08/22 Aiimee c49
09/05/22 Aiimee c48
09/01/22 Aiimee c47
08/29/22 Aiimee c46
08/26/22 Aiimee c45
08/11/22 Aiimee c44
07/14/22 Aiimee c43
06/15/22 Aiimee c42
06/04/22 Aiimee c41
05/27/22 Aiimee c40
05/19/22 Aiimee c39
05/18/22 Aiimee c38
05/11/22 Aiimee c37
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
408 Reviews sorted by


Aker
Aker rated it
October 2, 2021
Status: c311
In this novel keep a very very open mind, specifically towards the MC, because trust me you'll need it later. I also used to be like anyone else when I first started reading this novel, annoyed, flabbergasted by Mo Ran, and then the slap came right on my cheeks, and boy was I dead!

He's the one in this novel who literally taught me you cannot judge a book by it's cover because you don't know the full story. I was hurt, broke to the point of driving me crazy, and... more>> I could do nothing but curse *that* a*sshole to death for what they make out of Mo Ran.

To be honest, these so called morally righteous people barking in the comment section about how much they hate Mo Ran, tell me what would you do if you someday become a full ass puppet of someone (that sounavabich) and commit some heinous crimes, should I make you accountable for all those unimaginable things 'you did'? Or should I hug you and sing you forgiveness because you are the victim?

I think you have your answer. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Ashteee
Ashteee rated it
August 31, 2021
Status: --
The people equating this novel to other r*pe turns to love interests novels must not have read the whole book. Mo Ran is the ultimate victim in this novel and yet he still continuously sacrifices himself to make up for his crimes, that he was forced into committing. The author does an exceptional job creating each characters personality so through this we can understand that Chu Wanning is actually an intelligent character and doesn't just fall victim to baseless emotions that are often depicted in r*pe turns to love novels.... more>> He thoroughly understands the trauma that Mo Ran went through and knows that it was him who should have protected Mo Ran.

Spoiler

also for those who are upset about Mo Ran's soul joining with Taxian Jun's soul in the end you are ignoring that Taxian Jun is also a victim even after all the ab*se he gave to Chu Wanning. Taxian Jun was the product of the curse that was placed on Mo Ran and was unable to feel anything but loathing and hatred. Once his soul was no longer being manipulated he ended up sacrificing himself to save an entire world. I think it's fair for the distorted/manipulated Mo Ran to also have redemption especially since he suffered and lost more than anyone else

[collapse]
<<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
rice cake sprite
rice cake sprite rated it
June 30, 2021
Status: --
I am actually a chinese reader who has read the original story and has finished the whole story and I just want to say that THIS WAS WORTH READING TO THE VERY END

I understand how Mo ran is acting really crappy-ly and that the bad things happening to him just seems like the author trying to earn him pity point but I am so glad now that I wasn't quick to judge him. This author is very good at capturing humanity and although I'm usually skeptical of redemption arcs this... more>> was good beyond belief, even the "villain" so to say was not just a black and white character, everything depends on perspective. And trying not to spoil it here but Mo ran and Chu wan ning are seriously a match made in heaven, nothing has touched me so much, like, ever.

for those who are looking forward to the confession:

Spoiler

its very soon guys stay strong!it's gonna happen in ch179~ even when I'm rereading it I feel so happy for them I actually smile at my screen XD hopefully y'all will enjoy o (* ̄▽ ̄*) ブ

[collapse]
<<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
jtlmi
jtlmi rated it
April 23, 2021
Status: c149
There's not enough tears in my body that could sufficiently be shed for Chu Wanning. My heart bleeds and aches for him. I think the most prominent emotions I've consistently felt besides the occasional humour at the comedic parts would be grief, empathetic pity, and a sour squirming retching sort of sensation of watching someone go through pure injustice.

As for Mo Ran... he's a poster child for a male yandere in its rawest and most toxic form. Obsessive, psychotic, violent, malicious, devoted... I've never been curious about what it would... more>> be like to watch a Yandere mistake their love for loathing but this novel has truly enlightened me.

If MDZS was a fluff between a kuudere and a deredere– 2Ha is about the turbulent entanglement between a yandere and a cross between a tsundere/kuudere.

I've been told it's a
Spoiler

HE

[collapse]
but I'm currently not close to completing this novel so I can't confirm.

As someone who avoids tragedy tags like the rotten plague, I picked this up for the overwhelmingly positive reviews and they're not wrong. This is just one of those novels that you can't miss out on because despite the rollercoaster ride I'm on emotionally at the moment, 2Ha has still left a profound impact on me.

The romance is... worth the read. Absolutely 100% worth the read.

Much like the beloved HP quote "You're going to suffer, but you're gonna be happy about it?" <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
kyn
kyn rated it
March 20, 2021
Status: Completed
A vast sea of misunderstandings. Not even a speck of land could be seen. It is like endless frustration with no way out.

I am not going to talk about or attempt to summarize the story here. I'll go straight to how I feel about the book. I love the characterization, enjoyed the slow-burn romance and growth of the characters. The fleshed-out characters, even the supporting characters, are pretty well rounded. The backstories of the characters are intriguing and well written as well. These are the best parts of the book.

The... more>> not so great part is, I think the author is out to torture the poor readers, with.....

a) Endless misunderstandings. I find it suffocating and frustrating.

b) Too many repetitions. The author and even the characters keep repeating their own words over and over again.

c) Spoonfeeding the readers. I don't need that. I can think and decide for myself. Thank you.

d) Information dump.

The book has the potential to be good and better than what it is now. That is.....

...... if there are no overly annoying endless sea of misunderstandings.

..... if the author knows less is more with the number of conflicts.

..... if the author knows there is no need to over-inflate the angst and tragedies to gain the reader's pity.

Lastly, if we do not have to put up with the repetitive details and the information dumps, it will be a great book.

There are some redeeming features like times when the plot hits gold and made a deep impression, even earning tears and heartbreak from the reader. The main couple is so lovable that you can't hate but want to protect them. On top of that, I also enjoy the exciting non-consensual s*x s*ave parts. I love the fact that the top is physically taller and bigger than the bottom. Fond that the top is manly and dominant. Always a joy when the top is physically dominating. I like manhandling that oozes thick male pheromone. A feisty bottom is a cherry on top. I am glad the books ace these elements.

To sum, the book is driven by misunderstandings and a mountainous amount of conflicts heaped upon the poor main leads. Books with too many unnecessary conflicts and misjudgements could lead to the annoyance and frustration of the readers. I love angst in books, but not angst just for the sake of it, as it is a cheap poor effort to manipulate pity from the readers.

I read this book in preparation for watching the upcoming Chinese drama adaptation of it. I would still watch the show despite experiencing some fallout with the book itself, hoping that it would be different.

* Reviewed on March 20, 2021. Read the Chinese Novel via TTS. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Sakura Dream
Sakura Dream rated it
March 4, 2021
Status: Completed
I really love this novel. So much angst, literally my type. I cried so bad in some chapters and the plot is totally amazing (a huge roller coaster ride with massive knives). I've read it nearly a year ago and still remember the plot, which I mostly forget for most novels. For the first time, I read the novel so so fast, it was also the first time I read and cried to death. Fortunately, the ending is HE. Otherwise, I am afraid that even a pack of tissues is... more>> not enough. (The translations are not finished yet and so continue to read it with my not-so-bad Chinese. The MTL was also pretty well) Loves every character in the novel, the truth is not always what you have seen.

For those who don't like Mo Ran by just reading a few chapters or so, please read it till the end by only then judge it. The same goes for me, I hate Mo Ran for so s*upid and ignorant in the beginning and thought Chu Wan Ning deserves more and felt really sad for him. BUT, I WAS WRONG! When I read more and more with great curiosity, the truth is revealed slowly by slowly. I appreciate how the author finally built something up and crashed it all of a sudden. The reborn Mo Ran step by step finally realized the overall truth behind him and also for what he did and why he was like that in his last life were all in a plot by someone, which costed Mo Ran's whole life but he didn't hesitate to lose everything just to save Chu Wan Ning!

Spoiler

Mo Ran was poisoned/cursed instead of Chu Wan Ning by someone (whose plot is more than to turn the entire cultivation world upside down). The vicious poison which later turned him into a nearly alike inhumane demon and made him only felt hatred rather than love, cruel than kind. This was the reason why he didn't remember any Shi Zun goods on him, except Shi Mei (guess it why *cough*). This was only a small part of it, read more to explore. Mo Ran was once a kind, innocent child, how his mom told him not to hold grudges upon others and listened sincerely to her, how he was saved by a young master on the cold winter night and felt great gratitude to him (yea, that young master was young chu wan ning). He remembered it all until that incident, poor Mo Ran. Glad that he reborn when everything is not yet out of control. Overall, what I want to say is Mo Ran deserves Chu Wan Ning and the same goes for the reverse.

[collapse]

I will say it again, THE TRUTH IS NOT ALWAYS WHAT YOU HAVE SEEN!

Mo Ran x Chu Wan Ning, an incomparable match made in HEAVEN!

Anyway, give it a try. I highly recommend it. BUT PLEASE DO CHECK THE TAGS!
Spoiler

THESE TAGES ARE NOT FOR DECORATIONS AND THEY ARE SPOILER WARNINGS FOR TRUTH. IF IT DOESN'T SUIT YOUR TASTE PLEASE DON'T BOTHER READING IT AND LOVE YOURSELF.

[collapse]
<<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
sumii
sumii rated it
January 30, 2021
Status: Completed
This is such a well written novel. It is so well written that at the end, it was really hard to hate the bad guy/guys. Instead of hate, I ended up pitying them. Just when I thought I finally know a certain character very well, I learned that I know nothing yet. Everyone has their own story and their own secret and it is as equally harsh as the other's. No one's life is perfect.

The novel is full of sufferings. I honestly lost count of how many times I cried.... more>> However, after all the sufferings, you'll be rewarded with tears of laughter. The extra chapters are super funny and at the end you'll be so emotional that you couldn't help but wish them all to continue living happily in their world.

I highly recommend this novel. It is the best BL novel I read so far. Everything gets wrapped up at the end really well and there is no questions left hanging like other BL novels. If you get turned off by MoRan at the beginning, please don't drop the novel. Continue reading because it is worth it. Yes, he is not a good person BUT he will redeem himself... and when you find out everything at the end, you'll cry to no end. Keep in mind that everything the author wrote has a connection and a reason. Even a tiny small detail is clue to a big secret. So pay attention and happy reading. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
wxbichen
wxbichen rated it
December 10, 2020
Status: Completed
When danmei fans said that this novel would make you cry, I thought they were just exaggerating what they felt. But when I read this novel? It made me feel again what I felt when I was still on the process of moving on. This really made me feel so nervous and I was in pain af. Honestly, it made me don't want to continue reading this novel, but everything is worth it when I got to the end, though, I don't kinda liked the ending part. 💓
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
hejikkk
hejikkk rated it
June 6, 2020
Status: c120
...i should have checked the tags. my eyes
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
frailsnail
frailsnail rated it
June 3, 2020
Status: Completed
Like all readers, I have biases. I love angst. I love sadness. I love dumb tsundere character types. 2HA had it all for me. It has plenty of triggers and there are problematic tropes being used here. I think in the context of the novel, it makes sense, but it's still problematic.

This is the first danxia novel I have ever finished and it captivated my attention in a way no other novel had. Do I think it's perfect? Absolutely not. Does it come close? Not really. But, it definitely has... more>> a special place and I feel it deserves a five and everyone should check it out because it's a damn enjoyable ride.

Book 1, to me though, is a masterclass of angst writing (and I have to really credit Rynn for a wonderful translation). This was the book that made me cry like a little baby multiple times and kept me crying and on the edge of my seat. We are introduced to Mo Ran, our dumb husky, and Chu Wanning, our dumb cat. One thing 2HA does amazingly is characterization. Quickly, they become almost like real people. Their thoughts are extremely consistent, their characters have quirks and personality that make them feel real. The side characters (notably Xue Meng) also feel alive and add to the story. Shi Mei was the flattest, to me, in Book 1, but don't worry -- we'll talk about him later. The plot and pacing was tight and flowed wonderfully. It starts off a little slow, but literally after chapter 10, the chapters began to fly by. Arcs came and went beautifully, the plot introduced questions and tension as well as reveal flawed characters. We had stakes. No one was perfect, far from it.

As an aside, I love stakes. To me, it builds tension and investment. I want to know if my characters will survive and what are the consequences. I don't want them to steamroll through the novel. Tangent aside, this is something I love in movies, TV, and novels.

Anyway, Book 1 was amazing to me. Book 2 and 3 I had to read an edited MTL and I think that hindered my enjoyment. But, there were more character development for all the characters, side characters included. It really hit home just how dark and bleak this world can be. Things feel hopeless often and boy is it delicious. However, Book 2 also had some of the most positive and happy moments for our main characters. The farm arc is a wonderful break after Book 1 and, no real spoilers, but it really helps quenches the thirst. Book 3 reveals more about the plot and you really realized how interconnected the lives of the characters are. Things sometimes feel unsatisfying and the conclusion really left you with a 'that's it?' feeling. Does it fit? Yes. But is it like the other novels I've read? Not really.

Issue with Book 3

Spoiler

Although I thought it was delicious for angst and really showed how good Mo Ran originally was. The demonic flower is a bit of a cop out and undermined Mo Ran's development in Book 1. He's a character who has done bad things and had potential for hate, adding the flower to me felt unnecessary. It hurt to know he took a bullet for someone, but it also ruined the impact of his development for me because we now have something to blame other than him. I can't really explain it properly and need to really settle my thoughts, but this plot point is something I both hate and love. I could have done without it, but some moments created from this reveal were golden.

[collapse]

Book 2 and Book 3 really made me fall in love with Mo Ran. In Book 1, I was hesitant about him, but his development was remarkable. The other characters, Xue Meng, and side characters like Ye Wangxi Nan Gongsi, etc, also have their moments and they feel real and fleshed out as well. In general, I think our main characters do stand out the most, but I have to give credit to meatbun for making her side characters memorable in their own rights.

I know I sort of brushed past Book 2 and 3, but the MTL translation was a bit to be desired. I might update and reveal once I finally read a full fan translation of 2HA from beginning to end. Overall, I think this is wonderful and highly rec to anyone interested in crying their butts off and falling in love with Chu Wanning. Warning -- some scenes genuinely are problematic, but there's still plenty to love about it regardless. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Achiless
Achiless rated it
December 30, 2019
Status: Completed
Edit: so basically we'll get a drama lmao it better not f*ck up. But Wannings actor is so on point, he alone is going to support the rating.

This novel is seriously so good, that I finished it with MTL (which usually makes me drop the novel) and I STILL like it so much that it's one of my favourite novels.

... more>> Story

You usually have either focus storyline or focus BL. Meatbun however is one of the rare autors to have actually woven those two together AND NAILED IT. Their relationship is related to the plot, yet it doesn't overshadow it (if that makes sense). The romance didn't make me cringe at all and it is not introduced incredibly late like MXTX's novels (no shade I love MXTX), but it also isn't an easy-going hey beautiful I saw you standing there so let's f*ck romance. I'm looking forward to see how China is going to censor all the gay and substitute it with brotherhood. Prob in the Beloved Enemy style. I hope I'm not giving them any ideas.

So our MC Mo Ran basically kills himself after he's become the most powerful yet most hated figure in the world, and he is reborn to when he's 16y (?) old. The reason for his blackening is the death of his crush in his previous life, so now that he is reborn in a time where his crush is still alive he decides to abandon his previous (past life) path and protect his crush. But nothing is as it seems BECAUSE THIS NOVEL HAS LIKE 10 PLOT TWISTS??????? LIKE 10. Authors try their hardest to come up with a plot twist and usually fail to deliver a good one, but Meatbun just casually throws 10? Or something like 10 I dunno what you consider a plot twist but uhm at least 5 like bro wtf???? A fking great god.

The story is so complex yet not difficult to follow. Everything is clearly well thought out by the writer and no chapter has a written-on-impulse kind of feel to it. The only con is that a certain event prior to a plot twist takes in my opinion too much time/pages, but that can also be because the arc didn't interest me.

There are r*pe scenes but you can argue that it isn't romanticised as... (I don't know if it's a spoiler?)
Spoiler

... the MC (gong) knows he's wrong and tries to somehow make up for it in his present life. So it becomes a healthy relationship omg.

[collapse]
It's also arguable that it is romantacised as the scenes are pretty explicit.

The emotional level is also so incredibly high. I know something is good when it makes me cry.

Characters

The main characters are perfect round characters that go through developments and aren't too basic. Ofc some mainstream characteristics like a cold beauty dressed in white are to be found, but these characteristics add to the charm instead of making it boring.

The author has done an INCREDIBLE job at organising the timeline, so the actions of the main characters are all eventually tied to past events and explained really well, and I really want to applaud Meatbun for it because I haven't seen anyone doing a better job. A fking talent.

Style

The translators did a really good job, and I think the MTL was also alright. The style isn't easy primary school level, but not difficult that you have to re-read sentences to understand what's exactly going on. It's just right. There are ofcourse Chinese proverbs etc, but that doesn't really prevent you from understanding the event and the translators also try to make it understandable. If you use MTL however you're f*cked, but again the story is still perfectly to follow.

Conclusion

Just read it and cry. <<less
6 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
meliksu
meliksu rated it
May 6, 2024
Status: c88
For a novel hugely popular I expected it to be at least gripping but unfortunetly its extremly long and boring. Nothing important happens for nearly hundred chapters. Angst is superficial, MC is immature and dumb.I cant understand why ML likes MC. Misunderstandings are annoying and going on forever. The characters even ML and MC are one dimensional and boring. There is no chemistry, no heart fluttering scenes. Dialogues are not exciting. Most important I dont feel any emotions of MC and ML like love, hate or even lust, and its... more>> because writing is simply not good.I cant even feel sympathy about ML for the hundreds of sacrifices he done for MC.I dont believe mc's love for ML and his regret at all. For years I wanted to read this novel and I am dissappointed I couldnt like it. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
xyz_8
xyz_8 rated it
September 24, 2022
Status: Completed
I was hesitating on reading this for months because of no proper translation and all these tags (r**e/mol*stat*** which I m not a fan of) but I finally started it for angst and I don't regret it at all... personally I don't prefer reading mtl specially for historical or cultivation novels but it was surprising when I straight up finished this long story...I went from hating/disagreeing with some characters to understanding them... the character of mo ran isn't ideal but very realistic. For the first 100 chps I really disliked... more>> him and probably nothing could make me have a favourable impression of him but I m glad I read till the end...I just want everyone to pls be patient and read till the end because things are very diff from what they seem to be at the start. One more thing I liked abt it other than the seme protagonist is the fact that MC isn't flawless or completely whitewashed. Mostly the pov we get is of MC with sometimes ml's perspective too. The unreliable narration by mo ran is frustrating but it adds element of surprise and sudden realisations. Even very small details are crucial and the world building was quite interesting and engaging. Chu wanning is my fav ML of all times (he deserves the best!) and all side characters are developed brilliantly. Contrary to what many think that mo ran is being victimised by author I think it's more of shedding a light on his thought process and reason behind his actions. I mean if u were to talk abt some incident u r very likely to add your explanation abt why u did smthg instead of just presenting facts. If the pov has being of cwn things wouldn't be that diff because he hardly blamed mo ran... that's what I hated abt him and that's why I came to respect that guy because of how calmly he can try to understand people who may have hurt him. Coming from someone who doesn't really believes in second chances or forgiveness.. the redemption and character development here was somewhat satisfying for me.

Thanks for reading my rant. If u r still here I just wanna say that give the book a try if u r not uncomfortable after reading the tags. I have missed out on many gems due to reading reviews beforehand. If I recall some things I would add to it although I suck at expressing my opinion.

(BTW there is a manhua version of this and I have heard abt official eng novel and drama series based on this so u can check those out too:)) <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
dCaitsith
dCaitsith rated it
April 18, 2022
Status: c170
I've been reading this for a while, until the previous translator took down their translations. And then this Tea Novel submit this translation, I was happy at first, and then I read it and felt my brains turned into congee. I really don't understand why no one stops them from translating. I've checked and I heard their translations of case file compendium is also a mess. Sometimes when I didn't understand what they wrote, I checked the raw for that paragraphs and input it in google translator and guess what,... more>> sometimes google translator is better, sometimes its worse.

Those 4 stars I give is for Meatbun and the previous translator (forgot the name), not for Tea Novel, in fact it's 4 and not 5 because of them. For anyone who just starts reading it, I suggest you wait for sevenseas, even though it's still months away. I'm going to wait for them too because I don't want Tea Novel wrecks a good story that Meatbun had worked so hard to create.

As for the story itself, it's completely complicated and full of heart slicings, and the little bit of smut here and there gives the story some colors and not a complee tragedy. Though sometimes I wondered how Mo Ran could be so idiot in his first life to the point of total blindness to the truth, perhaps that's just what it does to someone who's grieving. I was glad he got the "slap" after Butterfly Town though, and his character development after. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
This person is dying
This person is dying rated it
April 4, 2022
Status: -
Bro, the only problem this story has is its word counts.

No kidding! A lot of stuff can be annexed and you probably can get 30% of your time (and probably money) saved:

... more>>
Spoiler
  • foods description
  • grotesque stuff (probably author just want to write gore)
  • side-mission for over 5 chapters; suddenly it became slice-of-lifey
  • characters analysis on almost every characters
  • side characters' flashbacks and background story are almost a novella on its own
  • main characters' same inner thoughts retold over and over again, in different poems
  • all melodramatic thoughts to add to its melodrama
  • (more to add)
[collapse]

Because a lot of things are written in too much unnecessary details, that's why there are more people who get disgusted by the morality (or the lack of it) of the story.

For example:

Spoiler
  • Mo ran's reason for humiliating his shizun are much (arguably) acceptable if author didn't write too much DETAILS on the r*per inner thought while doing the deeds throughtout the story as if wanting to glorify it
  • excessive main couple's inner (lustful) thoughts towards each other makes the contrast between their passion too apparent when objectically this much different in temperature are quite reasonable
  • (more to add)
[collapse]

Too many word counts also made some plot twist already stale when it's opened.

Spoiler

Like about one character's true gender or about the villain's identity, etc. Since it's also pretty predictable.

[collapse]

Beside that, everything are actually pretty good if not some are average. At least they're not something big to consider cutting of one star.

You'll also get used to author's writing style who seems to like to be more colloquial because the use of too much ?? Or !! In the narrative.

After all it's a long ride, how can you not used to it??

But this word counts also made this book rating soar because of the blatant lustful thoughts of the characters, the smut, their melodramatic inner thoughts, the good characters analysis which makes (Mo Ran's) character development become chef kiss, etc.

So the problem, author has to pick better which one to write details and which one are not to. This also related to story pace.

Spoiler

A good book needs editing, and editing means annexing a lot of unnecessary stuff that this book producing like tree producing air. Since this story started as webnovel so it can't be helped.

But if it's started as published book, imagine your wasted time and money for every unnecessary words. And imagine buying the middle volume of this series and finding out it doesn't contain as much as 30% of meaningful content in other volumes. You'll feel cheated and want to roast the author.

[collapse]

The art of enjoying this book are to be able to tell WHEN to allow yourself being sweep by the current and when to stay detached, and WHEN to read in details and when to skim. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
sanlang3003
sanlang3003 rated it
December 15, 2021
Status: --
Translation: I have only read Rynn & Suika's translations (which they have since taken down). Their translation was pretty top-notch. I know I'm picky in saying this but Rynn was the better translator of the two, as I remember thinking halfway through that the translation suddenly seemed sloppier & less elegant/refined than the first half (that was when Suika took over). Please don't hate me, that's just my opinion... Both are excellent translators!

Story: I'm not gonna repeat what many reviewers have already said - you either... more>> love the story or you hate it (& it would do you well to read ALL the tags before jumping in).

Surprisingly, of all the f*cked up sh*t happening in the story (& I don't necessarily mean that in a bad way) the thing I realize I hated most was that Chu Wanning fell in love with a 15 year old Moran. Like, I really hate danmei where adults are crushing on children. People can argue all they want that it takes place in a different time/reality but still, it's hard to get into the story imagining a grown ass man being into a kid. I mean, also what is the appeal? A scrawny 15 year old that hasn't even finished going through puberty & probably has that awkward, screechy voice & peach fuzz mustache. Other than another 15 year old teen, why would adults be attracted to that unless they were a predator??

Ok fine, I tried to get through the story by pretending Moran was 20 years old when he got adopted by his uncle.

Then there's the r*pe. I understand that it was the terrible sh*t Moran did in his other life that he appears to regret, however he constantly gets h**ny & turned on whenever he has flashbacks of raping his Shizun. Like bro, if you truly regret the heinous actions of your past life, then those memories should actually make you sick & disgusted rather than turned on.

Characters: They're all wonderfully flawed, aren't they? I do like that. No one is perfect in this story & it makes me sympathize with them more. I do get annoyed by Chu Wanning & his whole "well this is who I am it's too late for me to change" bullshit. Who hurt you?? No, really - as I will probably never get to finish this story unless they officially translate to English! Moran has his tragic backstory - his character growth is interesting. Anyway, Meatbun is an interesting writer & I hope her works can get officially translated so I can finish the damn story! <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
CJchan092
CJchan092 rated it
November 10, 2021
Status: Completed
I hate r*pe but I love angst! Sadly, most angst stories do have r*pe. I was about to drop this when it was getting too f*cked up but I pushed through.

So... to anyone who has the same preference as me and has been experiencing the same thing I felt, I have one thing say: DON'T DROP THIS!

I understand those people who already dropped this but only those who finished are ones who truly know how gold this novel is. I've finished reading this for more than a year ago but... more>> the pain and beauty of this novel is still in my heart. It's sad to see people dropping this, but I'm telling you, you need to hang on!

This is not justifying r*pe because I hate it myself. You need to read it yourself to understand what I'm saying, because if you did drop this, you will miss out a hidden treasure.

Just one little thing to complain (MAJOR SPOILER, ENDING PART) :

Spoiler

MAJOR SPOILER, ENDING PART!

I didn't like that Mo Ran and Taxian-Jun shared one body. Like they're supposed to become one—possessive and aggressive but also good and obedient kind of Mo Ran. Won't that be the hottest and perfect Mo Ran? Imo, that was he really was supposed to be like. Now he seemed like he has a split personality. I didn't buy that it was because his scattered soul pieces were separated for too long because if that was the case, Chu Wanning should also had been the same. Tho his souls didn't really differ in personalities but they were still totally not the same. So there should have been a somehow or mild (?) split personality too.

[collapse]

Anyway, if you're really curious what changed my mind (MAJOR SPOILER, BIG REVELATION) :

Spoiler

MAJOR SPOILER, BIG REVELATION

There was a black seed/flower (I don't remember well) implanted in Mo Ran's heart. What was even more painful was it was originally meant to be implanted in Chu Wanning but Mo Ran stopped Shi Mei and offered himself instead. His last lines were confession of pure love before he finally lost his memories and slowly turn evil. 😭 I f*cking bawled! When everything was revealed, Mo Ran even told Chu Wanning he would do the same thing if that happened again.

[collapse]

Character development is 100/10! Story 100/10. A MUST-READ! <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
everydayisdanmei
everydayisdanmei rated it
September 17, 2021
Status: --
First, let me warn you, THIS BOOK IS NOT FOR ANYONE WITH A WEAK HEART. Hold your finger before commenting. I'm quite annoyed that some people gave this book a bad rating even though they've only half read it.

This book is the best book ever. The love story between Mo Ran and Chu Wanning is the most painful and sweet story ever. If you feel annoyed with Mo Ran's character who treats his Shizun very, very badly, you should come back once the book is fully translated, this book is... more>> truly a masterpiece.

Spoiler

For me, Mo Ran is the most unlucky character. His life was not smooth at all, he even accidentally hurt the person he loved he respected the most, the only person he wanted in this world. If only his love and sincerity for Chu Wanning were not that great, he would not have experienced all these cruelties.

[collapse]

Ugh, I never comment on NU because my English is bad and I apologize for that. But I can't stand the bad reviews some people have given here. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
BlackLoveInSpace
BlackLoveInSpace rated it
July 15, 2021
Status: Completed
Whether this novel is good or bad, there are endless discussions. Because it covers sensitive themes and it doesn't shy away from diving into detail. What I can assure you is that it will shackle you to read until the end and think about it endlessly at night. Hell, it even got into my dreams.

Characters

Both of the main characters are emotional wrecks

  • Chu Wanning - 9.5/10 - Happy little tree painted by Bob Ross-
Tsundere driven to the extreme. You probably had a period in your life of sheer... more>> coldness (probably in your teens). Chu Wanning feels like a very relatable character. He will not accept help, will not forget and though it seems he does not forgive, it is more to him than meets the eye.

He has reached a point where his reputation is well known by everybody. He hates himself and wants to change his attitude, but doesn't know where to begin and is aware that society will criticize him for changing.

There is a lovely dissonance between what he feels and what he shows, which leads to lots of conflicts. What I didn't really like about him is that he sometimes happen to lose consistency
Spoiler

, like when he cries for like 30 chapters straight. I'm not saying he is not allowed to show emotion, his character evolves a lot, but sometimes he gets too far from his mold

[collapse]
.

  • Mo Ran - 8.5/10 - hot king of hotness, did I mention he is sexy, very much so, and he has a huge shlong
Mo Ran doesn't knows much about emotion, doesn't understand himself, his feelings and the feelings of people around him, and doesn't even know that many words. Feels refreshing to have such a s*upid protagonist that the author doesn't simp ove- OH NO HE IS HOT. And we have to be reminded of this several times. Yes the part where Chu Wanning reads about his d*ck size is funny, but we don't need to be reminded of his sausage every few chapters.

What I like about him as a protagonist is how unreliable he is to the reader. Just when you thought you knew him quite well, you learn another thing about him that you never expected. That happens to the very end of the book. You think you know him, that you spent enough time with him. You never know him well enough.

  • Other characters- this story surprisingly holds very well its first two thirds with only 4 important characters. Xue Meng and Shi Mei seem like basic characters that do their job well and don't need several layers in order to work- but they get their own arcs later on! I was very pleasantly surprised.
There are only a handful of supporting characters, and they are well fleshed out. Also if you think there are not enough female characters (a sin of the genre, not this book in particular), you will be pleasantly towards in the end.

Action& Plot- Awe-Inspiring, Heartbreaking, h**ny

This book excels at sending you in a faraway place and stealing your thoughts away. The worldbuilding is great, exactly what one loves most about fantasy. This book has the most BEAUTIFUL celestial description passages I've ever read, and it's flexing them throught several parts of the plot- "Jincheng Lake was frozen without traces of snow, as if there were jewels made of glass across the sky and earth, the Milky Way itself fallen upon mere mortals, falling stars seen as far as ten thousand miles, a scene peerless in magnificence. It was as if one had truly journeyed to the end of humanity, to a world covered in beautifully untainted snow."

Sometimes I don't know if I'm reading Chinese or western fantasy- there are dragons and giant wolves, underworlds and dimension switching, immortality seekers and soulmates. I can feel the author's passion and everflowing imagination for regarding faraway concepts.

One think I was wondering while reading was whether Mo Ran was gonna adress the elephant in the room -his rebirth- and face his demons. Once this happens, it will feel like everything before that was just filler haha.

There are 2 kinds of people. Some want high stakes, save-the-world stories and other want more character driven and personal stories. This book managed to have it both ways. First two parts are more fun, random shenanigans and personal quests, while the last one is high staked.

The one thing I didn't like-
Spoiler

Mo Ran's degeneracy in his previous life just did not have to be due to an evil flower. Those fantasy devices belong in lazy stories with bad character development and motivation. Mo Ran needed no explanation or influence for what he has done- it was 100% in his character. He has already been fleshed out. It was believable and understandable.

I know the flower just amplified the hate that was already there, but it just felt like a big slap to the reader's face. Make it a story about the humans' condition, about how even the best-willed people can fall into darkness. Make it feel like he could be real. This "flower" worked at characterizing the villan at the expense of our protagonist's credibility.

I don't want a "he was good all along" protagonist. There is no trouble with having a degenerate as our MC.

[collapse]

Ending impressions- Walt Disney is rolling in his grave

Spoiler

I was hoping for a bittersweet ending. But it was the happy ending disney shit, suddenly and out of nowhere. Most of the plot twists were brilliantly foreshadowed, but hoho not this one. There is a simple solution for this- cut the last 2 chapters. You got the perfect ending right there. But no, we must please the yaoi fangirls.

(also, Mo Ran not only lives, but he is bipolar now. Which made the whole dramatic parting between Shizun and Taxian-Jun kinda useless)

[collapse]

Conclusion- still a 10/10

I have been harsh in my review because you must be harsh with the people you love- just like Chu Wanning almost beat Mo Ran to death in the beginning. In truth, this story destroyed me mentally with how much I love it. I have read two thirds of it machine-translated because I just can't wait 16 years (yes I calculated) for the translation to be done.

This book rendered most of the books I've read until now kinda useless- it is simply that thought-provoking and better form all points of view. If gore and s*xual themes don't upset you, then it is something you totally must read in this lifetime.

Yes, it is not perfect. But if it makes you care so much about it to the point you love to hate it and love it again, then it desreves a clean 10.

BONUS- translation: sadly, the translation is as of now in a limbo. I see that novelupdates has removed the main translation and doesn't even have links to the machine transaltion. Also, I don't like the main translators' attitude. I will gladly buy the books when they are officially out in english. The documents were locked form downloading and I couldn't even extract a few quotes. Right now, even if it changed my life and view over some themes, I feel like it's not destined towards me, the english speaking audience.

Let's hope that the drama adaptation will bring it to light and we will someday have it on our shelves. Until then, if you plan to read it, the internet is fortunately still full of links and gateways. <<less
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Hale_eee
Hale_eee rated it
November 27, 2020
Status: c141
As someone who have read Grand master of demonic cultivation and Heaven official's blessings, I've always thought nothing else would make me cry. But, how wrong was I!!! I wasn't quite convinced with first few chapters but this had me hooked. Despite the fact this had me shedding liters of tears, this a master piece. Truly a piece of art <3
5 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
1 3 4 5 6 7 21
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.