Greetings, Ninth Uncle

Description

Links are NOT allowed. Format your description nicely so people can easily read them. Please use proper spacing and paragraphs.

Cheng Yujin was the elder twin sister, who was supposed to be engaged to an excellent man. However she later learned that her fiance, Marquis Jingyong, had proposed to her because he mistakenly recognized her as her younger twin sister. Marquis Jingyong and her younger sister had a deep relationship, and after many twists and turns, finally broke through all hardships and became eternal lovers. While Cheng Yujin was the villain who replaced her sister’s good marriage, kept framing her sister, and hindered the main couple to be together. A really wicked older sister and poisonous late wife.

After the younger twin sister was reborn, she revealed Cheng Yujin’s ‘conspiracy’ early on. Everyone scorned her, and her so-called fiance was indifferent. Cheng Yujin sneered and tore off their engagement letter in front of her fiance.

Everyone was gloating and happily waiting to see her regret her actions. However, before Marquis Jingyong had a chance to see Cheng Yujin’s regret, he saw his former fiancee marrying her uncle.

The ninth uncle of Cheng family was truly a hidden dragon, his real power frightening everyone.

***

Cheng Yujin, this coquettish little wife, lightly lifted her eyebrows and casually said, “A mere Marquis Jingyong, is he worthy? Do you think that robbing him away will affect me?”

Almost forgot to say, ninth uncle wasn’t surnamed Cheng. His real name was Li Chengjing, the crown prince.

Associated Names
One entry per line
GNU
ยอดสามีของกุลสตรีอันดับหนึ่ง
九叔万福
Related Series
N/A
Recommendations
I Became The Stepmother of My Ex-husband (11)
Eight Treasures Trousseau (7)
The Yandere Came During the Night (6)
To Be A Virtuous Wife (6)
The Crown Prince in the Jade Pendant (4)
The Dreamer in the Spring Boudoir (4)
Recommendation Lists
  1. CHINESE HISTORICAL ROMANCE
  2. Matrimonio prima, amore dopo (letti o in lettura)
  3. Well-written Ancient China romance novels
  4. Strong Female Protagonist
  5. my everything.

Latest Release

Date Group Release
07/06/20 aerialrain c8 part2
07/01/20 aerialrain c8 part1
06/29/20 aerialrain c7 part2
06/26/20 aerialrain c7 part1
06/24/20 aerialrain c6 part2
06/22/20 aerialrain c6 part1
06/17/20 aerialrain c5 part2
06/15/20 aerialrain c5 part1
06/10/20 aerialrain c4 part2
06/08/20 aerialrain c4 part1
06/03/20 aerialrain c3 part3
06/01/20 aerialrain c3 part2
05/27/20 aerialrain c3 part1
05/25/20 aerialrain c2 part2
05/21/20 aerialrain c2 part1
Go to Page...
Go to Page...
Write a Review
213 Reviews sorted by


Gabi94
Gabi94 rated it
November 6, 2022
Status: --
The novel seems well written, but to be honest, the ML already pissed me off in the first few chapters.

He's the Crown Prince, (not a spoiler as it's said at the beginning) but he hasn't lived in the palace for many years, on the contrary, he's lived as an illegitimate son much longer than he's lived as Crown Prince, but for some reason, he's as arrogant as a prince who's been pampered his whole life. (Maybe this is explained further in the novel, but as this is... more>> not the kind of relationship I like, I will not find out)

He treats the MC with something that, if not disrespect, it certainly looks like. It's not that he's abusive, it's that he seems to think of her as a jumping monkey rather than a strong woman, and from there I lost interest in the relationship. Maybe it gets better, maybe not. Anyway, I really don't like that kind of relationship where the power dynamics are unbalanced between the couple.

He also seems to want to get in the MC's way before he's ready to take responsibility for her, and in this ancient setting plus MC's past and circumstances, that's even more irritating.

I don't think is funny or cute for him to disregard MC's struggles even before he knew for sure he liked her, seems egoistical and annoying, but that's just my opinion, maybe you can like him and the dynamics, I don't know. I just thought There are few (But still there are some) reviews here mentioning this so I gave my opinion in case you also feel uncomfortable and are searching for an excuse to move on from this novel. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Ziar367
Ziar367
September 1, 2022
Status: c134 part2
Highly recommended.

This novel is well written and amazingly translated.. Thank you to our author and translator for job well done.

I love the MC. She’s ahead of her time type of woman. Can stand on her own and able to handle her own ambitions. It may sound great but her character and outlook in life was a result of the lack of love she received very early on. She had no choice but to mature early. Had no one to rely on but herself. Her background is very sad if you... more>> think about it.

Very grateful for the ML. Respectful, not too overbearing, understanding and so sweet. I love their tandem to bits.

definitely a re-read. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Nonameschemer
Nonameschemer rated it
December 23, 2021
Status: Completed
Honestly a great female lead who isn't without flaws. She's a selfish, hypocritical, and extremely two faced person. The likes of which would in real life be greatly disliked by others. At the same time she's very logical, cunning and hard working person who's able to survive her less than fun life. She 100% DESERVES the respect and obsession people have for her. No one falls in love with her for some random reason that would take mental gymnastics to justify in real life. A peerless beauty, perfect in every... more>> way, but still is just a person at the end of the day. Although men are in love with her, everyone BUT the ML sees her as a bartering piece. Including herself.

Spoiler

Yujin WORKS for her flower reputation to the point its clearly an obsession. For example, even on her sister's return home she believes she cannot and will not be subdued by anyone. She has the desire to be the best daughter in law and legal wife. However she struggles the way ACTUAL ancient women do, instead of her sisters original tale. I also loved the way she found a way to adapt from pleasing mother in laws due to her destroyed engagement to pleasing men. All her life she's told she's boring and a stickler to rules. Now, she was twisting and turning to attract her perfect husband, all while still staying within a model role model girl in ancient china. Unlike Yumo, who although saved a life still got undressed and laid with a man the entire night. Which could have gotten her killed if the circumstances were slightly different. Yujin is using her people reading abilities and attention to details to lure and trap husbands. All while her future husband is boiling in rage, and fighting off his love rivals

[collapse]

Their love is the MOST realistic love story i've seen from a CN novel in a long time. Most of these unbalanced status romances, require at least one or realistically both braindead main characters in order to function usually. I'm sorry but in ancient china. Promoting a maid in to empress WHILE having an empress from a strong family is impossible. Also having a person reject you a million times in any time period, despite growing up wealthy and having anything you want WON'T have the person try harder in a way that you'd like. Yujin is naive to the ML's affection for a long time, but not because she's dumb. It's because she's selfish. A selfish person, can never judge someone else with pure intentions because they know what they'd do in that circumstance. She would never marry someone poor and powerless for love, so she doesn't expect someone to do the same for her. Her character growth isn't that much in all honesty. Expecting her to change from being the all perfect eldest miss to a traditional heroine is not going to happen. Most other MCs in historical china would most likely die in ancient china. Those MC's would probably die in modern times too, defying authority in ANY time period will get you killed unless you're really really lucky.

This MC would survive in any time period because she knows her strengths and weaknesses and doesn't need anyone to save her since for the first time "shocking" she isn't helpless. She doesn't rely on the ML, but because he shows her what love is like for the first time in her life they have a happy and good marriage. Instead of most common troupes of opposites attracts, with fiery passionate (and toxic forceful obsessive) love we get to see calm and healthy relationships. The ML doesn't sexually harass MC, (which is a big deal since CN novels have a tendency to require that for plot development) (at one point he even thinks " hey even though I find her attractive, she values properness and it would be disrespectful to go any further) the two ACTUALLY talk about their problems, and both parties put in mutual effort into their relationship. A cold ML who doesn't have face paralysis and undeserved powers that everyone listens to them despite being disgustingly cold, peerlessly rude, and exhibiting signs of a personality disorder. By all means MC is a typical villainous character who's well fleshed out and ISN'T obsessed with a man. She's selfish, self centered, and overall cares about herself more than anyone else. Which is why, in order to make someone like her fall from grace you would need an incredible amount of bizarre circumstances to subdue her into seeming like a mean, brainless, and excessively cruel person.

ML is a ACTUAL capable person who is naturally aloof, better-than-thou person who's suited for power since he is equally manipulative, calloused, and perfected like MC. He would never fall in love someone who's helpless and useless like MC's sister unless he was beaten to an inch of his life, reincarnated without his personality, and injected with a strong dose of s*upidity. He still an ancient man and has typical thoughts of territorial, lust, and the desire to cripple his enemies. Unlike his fictional counterparts with similar qualities, he has the ability to back up his claims and people still barely tolerate his "lapse of judgement" due to following in love.

Will say I wouldn't have minded some explicit scenes in this novel, would have added to the depth. I also believe that the plot could have went on for longer. The second half felt wayyy to smooth vs the beginning half. It would have been able to expand ML and really show off his capabilities. It would be a bit exhaustive so I see why the author made it read like that. It would have felt good to see MC and ML struggle over an actual smart person, instead of a bit brainless people. It would feel more realistic to see their more cruel villain side <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Arina-chan
Arina-chan rated it
November 18, 2021
Status: c95 part2
This is such a great novel. MC is not someone you could say as a good person in a traditional meaning but she never went out of line with her scheming. In an Era and the position that she is in, I feel like she is very realistic and smart in all of her decisions which made me love this novel even more.

You can also see how many characters think, some you may personally think they're dumb and short sighted but if seen from their perspective, it makes sense in... more>> a way.

I recommend this for everyone, it's not always about face slapping or revenge like the other ancient Era novel and you would sympathize with both the ML and MC <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
hevaLaLuna
hevaLaLuna rated it
August 17, 2021
Status: c61 part1
Read until ch. 61 and I couldn't stand it anymore. What was originally written as an interesting pair / "power couple goals" turned into "girl boss" and "cuck turd". The main characters are dull because the author is dull. FL is written to be very calculating but is extremely s*upid and can read none of the emotions of the male character but just keeps on asking "Hmm, I'm talking with other men and this uncle turd gets madder and madder. I wonder what the problem could be? Hmmm? ". And... more>> the dude is like "I'm like a lion whose territory is encroached upon. Roar!! ". This girl could never compete with Han Yuxi, from The rebirth of Han Yuxi. Double sided embroidery my ass. Han Yuxi would wipe the floor with her and KO her in 0.1 seconds. Read that if you want to read about a Slytherin Female Character. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
CaliforniaMaki
CaliforniaMaki rated it
April 6, 2021
Status: Completed
MTL'd to finish this!

*sigh* What I like about this CN is that altho FL was rebirthed she didn't somehow make use of future events to be OP. She uses her brain and her gift of rhetorics to pulverize her enemies to shocked silence. 🤭 ML ofc is 🥰. Very supportive of FL and a super ML!! No stalking and violent tendecies 😊

This author is really good at creating atmosphere and painting the historical scenes with her words. It was quite wordy but you'll get through (MTL's 80% readable).

In my unpopular opinion, I tear'd up at in MTL 😅:

Spoiler

When Huo Changyuan finally realized that he should have loved Cheng Yujin in their past life, so it wouldn't have ended in her death and they would have lived together. I'm just a s*cker for tragic romance. But ofc, CY said she would have lived a good life with HC, but not a happy one 🥺. I just want to make it clear that she belongs with Ninth uncle 🥰.

[collapse]
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Shinygold13
Shinygold13 rated it
January 17, 2021
Status: Completed
I finished reading this months ago but never got around to giving a review.

I consider this novel one of my favorites because 1) she is not the typical cold blooded MC nor a real white lotus—ya know, the ignorant, almost dumb one—and 2) the story and its main couple appeals to my rational side.

The charm of this novel is that there is logic to things, to how characters act, how they struggle, how their motives shape their personality and life. It deeply resonates to the human psyche—how everything in life... more>> is mostly gray and not black or white and that most if not all of us just had to waddle through the muck and make the most of it.

The romance is slowburn but reasonable because it is based on the inner characters of the main pair. They are both introverts, shrewd, and secretive. I am happy that their love developed in such a matter-of-fact tone, a development which did not break their characterization.

There’s no passionate showcase, the kind where an outsider would awed and call it romantic. No, here, the love is quiet, boring, and true.

This kind of love is steady and one that can happen in reality. This is the kind of love that one can truly say, yep, they’re gonna get old together. No doubt.

And the icing on the cake is the side story—a funny albeit melancholic end. <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
lazykitty_99
lazykitty_99 rated it
September 22, 2020
Status: Completed
What I love about this novel is MC. She comes as strong, calm, rational and calculative person. I myself want to be like her.

She understands her circumstances and now how to use every resource to the best for her. Many novels show Fls to be op but I always felt how in a patriarchal world are those Fls allowed to do as they want. Even presently when equality is preached in many countries women doesn't have those equal rights..

This novel shows from MC prespective how women of that era makes... more>> calculations for the best outcome they could get.

MC in emotions is a very passive person as she herself felt neglect since she was a child so she never puts anyone in her heart and I love her firm determination for that. ML too has his bad past which could be considered as a reason for his initial liking for MC.

If MC existed in a free society I bet she would have been a successful person as she is very clear about her goals even ML love couldn't shake it at first.. Usually in most novels MCs with regular interactions fell in love with MLS but here Cheng yujin never got those feelings for Ml, she is a goal oriented person for her husband is a tool (well it's okay considering in that era there weren't much of feelings between couples) not part of her life (later though ML did win that place). I loved how ML despite his high position never forced MC for anything even loving him. He knows who he married and what type of person MC is. ML shows love isn't pushy, domineering rather respecting the person you love. He slowly does makes a place for him in MC heart. Even did that "talk" with MC on how he knows she considers a husband as a tool but as he fell in love so MC just needs to be by his side that's it, he doesn't wanna change her. There isn't passionate love but a gentle one which I love. Their love looks bland and plain but it's the most stable one. Both MC & ML never let their emotions guide them.

They understand each other circumstances and efforts and support each other. One of the funny things is how MC on knowing her marriage with ML first weighs pros and cons of marriage. Another funny incident how MC grandma believes MC could just send her husband to a concubine without any feelings.

MC can live a good life with any guy but only with ML she can live a happy life as only he understands her and can make a place for him in her small space. I guess it goes for ML too.

Another good thing. ML gives a proper 'ancestor law' to outsiders for not accepting concubines not just shallow reason of "love". Well he did told MC before marriage he wouldn't take concubines (for his love for MC and want of a peaceful loving family) which MC didnt believed much.

Just for MC I went through mtl but I admire ML too.

I enjoyed seeing MC calculate and scheme for best outcomes for her.

I have read author other novel (I'll be sister in law of ML) there I loved ML more and his healing process, ML of that novel looks more alive. In this novel I loved FL more , overall I liked this novel more maybe because here Lcj and Cyj love is more to my tastes (gentle and serene). <<less
4 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Peerless43
Peerless43 rated it
September 11, 2024
Status: --
The FL is rational and really smart, she know how to use her skills at the best and know how to read people well. But when it comes to herself and her own feeling, she is quite slow. But its make the love story really sweet.

The story has a great pace and the plot is interesting.
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Akime yuko
Akime yuko rated it
July 24, 2024
Status: Completed
The jealousy scenes alone deserve a 5 star from me, it's been a while since I feel so exhilarated watching a male characters consumed by jealousy from a novel and yet this novel manage to make me giggles and kicking feet like a teenage girl reading wattpad for the first time 😂

The romance is very steady and healthy since both have almost the same temperament so they match each other so well. They remind me of those royal couples in other novel who seems to be bound by marriage which... more>> the relationship remain only being respectful to each other and their activities seems to be boring as a couple except they're not and as days goes everyone can see how much love they had for each other from their daily Public-Display-Of Affection

As one of the maid said "Facts proved that smart people could live well anywhere. Two smart people put together only ended up twice as good. The so-called excellent men did not like smart and capable wives was merely a self-comfort of s*upid people."

My only qualms is
Spoiler

the lack of skinship between the lead, this novel is spg13. We don't even get a kiss scenes, like it happened but wasn't described and even cdrama wasn't this censored, so it kinda ruined the excitement as I was looking forward for their intimate scenes

[collapse]
<<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
problematicqueer
problematicqueer rated it
June 12, 2024
Status: Completed
I tried reading this story, dropped it out of boredom, then much later restarted from chapter 80 and finished it easily. GNU should've been a short story and not a novel, as the content is just too little. Cheng Yujin's struggles in the boudoir have low stakes and little scope. It should not have taken 80 chapters to tell that part of the story. Post-marriage, the main leads' conflicts are somewhat trivialized by the fact that all they need is the Emperor's support and they already have it ... more>>
Spoiler

(As soon as he stops supporting them, he drops dead. Protagonist halo FTW.)

[collapse]
but at least there are actually dangerous conflicts and intrigues in the palace, so it's better.

As other people noted, the story is long-winded. The MC rambles, the descriptions ramble, even the unnamed eunuchs ramble. It makes the story feel much longer than it is. There's a cute joke where the ML teases the MC for her rambling, and this feels like self-awareness on the author's part, but self-awareness is not enough. The author needs to work on not sounding like an exhaustive encyclopedia entry.

I liked the male lead and the female lead. Unlike most Chinese webnovels' male leads, this one doesn't substitute stoicism for personality and misogyny for faithfulness. He expresses respect and regard for women other than the MC, which shows that he likes her for who she is, not because he regards other women as worms. Meanwhile, the FL is smart and calculating. The author has a good grip on characterization: naïve characters seem naïve, smart characters really do come off as smart, etc. The pair have some cute moments together.

However. At more than one point the author rambles on and on about imperial majesty in an effort to stick gold to the FL and ML's faces. Imperial hagiographers would blush at some of these passages. You look up what a diyi + fengguan looks like and then look me in the eye and tell me that you find someone balancing a pearl-encrusted piñata on their head while swaddled in garish red tablecloth ~majestic and otherworldly~. Give me a break. They also try to pass off this farcical pomp & circumstance as some kind of ~heavy burden~ the imperial family ~reluctantly bears~ for the sake of the country. I bet, lmao. These ceremonies were for the sake of peacocking to an enclosed group of aristocrats who had to flatter them anyway. They had no more effect on the country than modern events like the Met Gala do (and even less without mass media). Most people would never hear of blue and white cakes at the such-and-such imperial banquet. Even if they did, it would do nothing for imperial power. People chewed poorly milled coarse grains while the imperial palace threw out entire banquets because the emperor held military power, not because the empress was such an on-trend fashionista. Needless to say, the author's unbridled fetish for imperial monarchy is more than a little distasteful (when it isn't being unintentionally funny).

The latter half of the epilogue is bad, skip it.

Spoiler

IDK why authors of regression (or in this case, "prophetic dream") stories can't suppress the urge to go muck about in the original timeline, but it sucks. The going assumption in a regression story is that the og timeline is gone, and now we get a happy ending. Whenever the author dips back into an og timeline, they undo all the work of resolving and avoiding the grievances of that timeline. It sucks! Plus, the "happy ending" turns out to be a SECOND regression (which implies we just created a THIRD timeline and thus didn't fix the first timeline at all). Worst of all, the author's creativity was all dried up so they just said that all the same events as in our main story happened in the og timeline, which means Cheng Yujin's existence and efforts don't matter at all to affairs of the court or inner palace, she's just a comfort doll for her hubby. :))) It sucks!! This is a very small part of the story but it's the very last part so it left a sour taste in my mouth. Skip it.

[collapse]

Small digression: this story seems to mislead readers about twins.

Spoiler

Cheng Yujin gets pregnant with twins and for some reason nobody seems to realize that twins can be a boy-girl pair prior to the birth. Fraternal twins are several times more likely than identical twins, and they have a 50-50 chance of being a boy-girl pair. In other words, boy-girl twins account for near-half of all twin births, but the author even calls boy-girl twins extremely rare. IDK if the author is misinformed or if they're misinforming others for the sake of drama, but it's reasonable to say they should've looked this up before stuffing inaccurate medical information into the mouths of ancient medical professionals who are otherwise treated as reliable sources.

[collapse]

Cheng Yumo could be said to be the second protagonist of GNU as well as its antagonist, but her story isn't focused on past chapter 80. There is a scene where Cheng Yujin scolds Huo Changyuan for his atrocious behavior as a husband that for me rates as the best scene in the book. This could have been a turning point for Cheng Yumo, but it wasn't.

Spoiler

Her story fizzles out like a wet firecracker as we get the unsatisfying and unconvincing revelation that actually, Huo Changyuan was in love with Cheng Yujin and just transferred that love to Cheng Yumo (??? Utter gibberish lmao). Then they get no more scenes.

[collapse]

It's a shame because side pairs like Cheng Yumo and Huo Changyuan often serve as seasoning to the main pair's healthy but bland porridge. But no seasoning is allowed in this story.

GNU has some hits and some misses but is overall defined by its low stakes, low tension and low tempo, culminating in a profound blandness that the author seems bizarrely smug about both within the story itself and in the afterword. While I agree with the author's sense of relationship ethics - a love full of betrayal and drama indeed makes for an unsightly love - the point of story-telling is primarily to be interesting, not to avoid being unsightly. Not to mention I've read plenty of stories that had an ML and FL who respected each other but still managed to create exciting relationship drama or relied on fast-paced storytelling to avoid boredom or constructed a riveting story to which the relationship merely added flowers to brocade. This story is so oddly self-satisfied with its depiction of a normal, healthy relationship that it forgets to add substance. 3/5. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
SoulineMist
SoulineMist rated it
June 12, 2024
Status: Completed
This was my first time reading a cnovel and I freaking love it! 😍 This was such a great novel. I love Cheng Yujin's personality and how fleshed out her character is. She is strong, calm, and confident. The ML is Li Chengjing, he's such an understanding and kind ML definitely a green flag. Their relationship and interactions is literally "charm" and "communication". Absolutely love this story, in the end what I can say to summarize this is that People become what they are because of their upbringing and environment.... more>> Yujin learned to be tough because she lacked affection growing up. Go and read this you all ✨☺️♥️

Here are some of the lines from the novel that I wanna share cause it stuck to me:

Crown Prince and Huo Changyuan are products on the views of adults who surrounded them.

The so-called excellent men did not like smart and capable wives was merely a self-comfort of s*upid people.

Cheng Yujin, who everyone unanimously thought to be too rigid, proved with practical actions that a truly capable person could do well wherever they were. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Alice.H
Alice.H rated it
April 27, 2024
Status: Completed
Comeback to read this again after I noticed it completely translated.

A good example of how upbringing can make 2 people behave the opposite way.

... more>>
Spoiler

Yujin (FL) and Yumo (2nd FL) were twins that live separately.

To me, deep down both of them actually have the same personality. Both of them were selfish, greedy, and manipulatives.

The difference was that Yujin had a high self-awareness, she knows her limit. Yujin would play victim if it's necessarry but unlike Yumo, she would never immerse herself in the act.

In one of the chapter Yumo's mother reminded her that the only thing she need to have a good life was her husband's love. With that love she can control her in-law, concubine, and servants, forgetting that there's no one set of rule for everyone.

Her mother simply raise her to be narrow minded and spoiled, while Yujin has to live on edge everyday with her adoptive mother.

Before Yujin married, the palace send female officials to teach her. Yujin was so graceful and elegant that they can't pick up any mistake. They keep waiting for Yujin's pretense to fall only to be dissapointed later.

The thing is she never pretend. She apply all those strict rules in her daily life for years. That is simply how she live her life so that nobody could bring her down.

[collapse]

Also

Spoiler

It's a nice novel where the birth of twins from FL and ML could be justified because FL herself were twins xD

[collapse]

The only thing that makes me sad was the story near the end.

Spoiler

There's a pair of brother and sister that died because of empress's nephew. The brother die to protect his sister while the sister die to avenge her brother. Even thought that incident help to toppled them later, it's just left a bitter taste in my mouth.

[collapse]
<<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
heminasti
heminasti rated it
March 5, 2024
Status: Completed
The FL has one of the more interesting personalities I've read in a while. She's excessively precocious, but that strength is also her weakness.

The ML doesn't have as much personality as the FL, but he's likable. He's capable and devoted.

The pace is languid, even a bit slow. Then wrapping up the politics happened swiftly at once near the end. But it was very complete and relaxing.

... more>> While there are sweet scenes, it's very PG—it even skips their first kiss, which even a Disney movie shows.

BTW, repeat after me. Having "a setting" is not the same as having "world-building." A setting is a basic, world-building is advanced. You probably mean "the setting" not "the world-building." <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Brandnesha
Brandnesha rated it
November 22, 2023
Status: --
I wanted to like it I really did but compared to other historical romances this was subpar. The Romance between the main leads felt off. And as I read further it felt like a chore, bland and boring.

It's just my opinion.
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Renaechan
Renaechan rated it
October 20, 2023
Status: Completed
I usually get a little annoyed with big palace dramas and all the intrigue, it feels like a soap opera. This was highly enjoyable. The relationship between the main leads was really well done. The key to any good marriage is communication. Love the story!
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
chasingcars2
chasingcars2 rated it
June 15, 2023
Status: extra 2 part4
She was of one the most rational FL that I’ve ever read. Love for her was not even an option, but I’m glad that she found it anyway. It’s good, romance is not really the focus, or that blatant but you can feel their growth as a couple, and their companionship.
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Staringatastar
Staringatastar rated it
May 21, 2023
Status: Completed
I'm breathless after reading this book. How is it possible for the author to create such smart, perfectly flawed characters? The FL is so beautifully crafted. Rational and sharp. Independent and able to fight for herself. Constrained only by the restrictions of her time period to fail without the support of others, so desperately conniving to steal that support in any way possible. She is so calculating and cold because she had to be from birth. But I get the sense that she is naturally very soft hearted given the... more>> chance.

The ML is just as good. Equally rationale because he has had to be to get where he was. But raised with the power to grab what he wants if something catches his fancy. Secretly reveres love and those who can give it to him. However, smart enough to decipher others' motivations and understand that he will likely never get sincere love. I thought the extra really helped answer any lingering questions the reader might have had about what happened in the first life.

I enjoyed reading about these characters - they're just the type of people I like. Fiercely intelligent ones that find themselves unable to suppress the slow creep of affection due to admiration and repeated shows of dependability. There is no fiery passion, in fact, this story argue that fiery passion is the least reliable.

I love how perfectly the ML and FL complement each other - you get the sense that they're in an equal relationship with mutual respect. And I don't mean equal in that they are doing the same things (they do have the restrictions of the time period after all), but equal in that both are contributing similarly to their wellbeing. The FL doesn't just dither and wait for a hero. She fights. She calculate. She evaluates situations with clear eyes. I usually hate BG romances because of how weak the female inevitably will be. They'll be overwhelmed into s*upidity by love. Or they'll stop doing anything the instant they have love. Or they'll just be resigned to being unable to do anything other than acting cute and relying on their lover. In a bl, at least the two start from a position of possible equity. But in this book, both characters start from such different positions and are actually so similar. They're more equal in the severely restricted environment of ancient China than many romances I read set in the "liberated" modern world (Chinese or English).

The story also shows how there is often a discrepancy between what others see and what a person is experiencing. This is especially important as much of real life is so focused on comparing yourself with others, or creating that perfect Instagram-perfect image. Someone might look to be having the perfect life - with wealth, love, and status - but others don't know the struggle they have to go through to maintain such a life. I love that. Don't ferment jealousy for others' lives, just focus on making yours the best it can be. <<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Anner
Anner rated it
May 3, 2023
Status: c98 part2
I think this author's greatest flaw is focussing a lot more on telling than actual showing. Often, we get one dialogue line and then the next half of the chapter is some character's musings - about things that we have already read about a half dozen times. The first third of the novel was really great and had me hooked, but now I can't stand the endless paragraphs of character's introspections that are really not written in a witty or interesting way filled with new information. Even the paragraphs that... more>> do introduce new information are written without clever exposition or with an interesting perspective. It's mostly boring information dumping.

The longer this novel gets, the easier it gets to spot its weaknesses.

Spoiler

The FL for example. I love that she is calculating, but that doesn't mean she can't have emotions, hidden wishes and desires. She's not the sentimental type, granted, but still, there were so many scenes especially with the ML where she showed emotion only for us readers to be told this was all fake, and then after the lake incident in the ML' secret residence the sudden outburst of emotion was supposed to be real? That scene felt so fake to me as a reader, I was honestly stunned. It felt like the author was unable to get a grip on her/his own character and often wrote her in a way that best suited the current plot but without different emotions and thoughts.

What is the purpose of the Huo guy remembering the past? Or for the FL, for that matter? Except for Yumo, I'm scratching my head why there's a need for the other two to remember. It doesn't seem to add anything worthwhile to the plot.

The FL's path to acquiring a husband plus the ML's journey to understanding his own feelings were way too draggy. That's when I first started losing interest. The author fails at developing characters properly or creating an engaging plot. All in all, there is unfortunately also too little intersting interaction between the FL and the ML - even though they live in the same residence! It feels like more than half the time it's the ML becoming unreasonably angry and jealous and the FL lying through her teeth to butter him up.

Another big con is that basically all side characters (except maybe the FL's servant girls) are unlikeable to some degree. There are no true sincere and good relationships without benefits anywhere to be found in this story. Even the Cheng aunt rushes over with her female juniors to capitalize on the fact that the FL has become the crown princess in order to curry favour with her own in laws. Disgusting.

Now I'm at the wedding night scene and the ML seems like the typical selfish and inconsiderate Chinese novel lover as well.

I've come so far and I wish I could pinpoint one plot arch that was truly interesting but I can't. And I think I will drop this soon.

Kudos to the translator's hard and dedicated work, though.

[collapse]
<<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
stony27
stony27 rated it
February 28, 2023
Status: Completed
Pretty good, but the writing for MC's character was kinda inconsistent.

The good

... more>>
Spoiler

MC's personality was pretty nice. No one in her family truly loves her so she does all the loving for herself. She's smart and will always act rationally because she doesn't believe that others will treat her sincerely, so she hardly ever takes their hurtful actions to heart. Eventually, she does understand that ML loves and would never betray her for anything, not even to secure the throne by marrying a nominal concubine.

ML was calm and assertive. Very standard of this author's ML's in that he's tall, handsome, competent, a dead-mother-avenger, etc. He treats MC very well and doesn't act tsundere when he realizes the way he likes her. He doesn't mind her career-minded approach to marriage and life in general and just asks that she honors their relationship as husband and wife by being the one person he can love and trust unconditionally.

In the previous life epilogue, ML dreams up the events of our novel and realizes that the person that he could've married and loved was his former niece, the Cheng Clan's eldest daughter Cheng Yujin (nice name btw this killed her prudishness a bit). He inquires about her and learns that she's already married. He doesn't give up though, and continues to refer to her as Eldest Young Lady (very rude to do this I think. it ignores her status as a married woman and disregards her husband) when he asks about her, only to learn that she's dead. Just wanted to include this in the parts I liked cos wow love me a good male homewrecker. I can only assume that he meant to hint to his underlings to find a way to change her identity and have her enter the palace as his woman when he called her by her unmarried title.

[collapse]

The bad

Spoiler

MC's character was supposed to be selfish, egotistical, and interest-motivated, so imagine my shock and repulsion when at the turning point of the story (when ML restores his identity as the Eldest Imperial Son and Crown Prince), she rescues a random ass child who falls into the freezing river thanks to his parent's neglect and his own s*upidity. MC spent the whole story as this no-nonsense person who has no qualms teaching a tough lesson to annoying kids and all of a sudden she wants to save a random child??? Who might turn out to be a little b*tch??? I almost vomited blood. Thankfully it was all a misunderstanding and she actually jumped into the lake to force the man she wanted to marry to jump in and save her (blah blah... saving her from drowning = skin 2 skin contact = the gentleman must not be a villain and take responsibility for the lady's loss of innocence by marrying her) but surprise surprise ML got news immediately and was the one who jumped in instead to save her.

MC also apparently had some charm as a cold beauty prior to being married (hence the attention from some men like Cai Zhanlin) but her married life with ML was so... bland. Other than the strip chess, I can't remember anything that was particularly passionate. I really liked her openly close (inappropriately so) /coquettish interactions with ML when they were still uncle and niece but after they got married, it's like she doesn't understand that her lovey dovey actions arouse desire and would often act like the biggest f*cking prude when it comes to fornication. I personally really hate this whole reserved lady insincerely saying no when in reality she means 'i don't mind' thing. How are people supposed to know which no means no and which no means yes?!!? Ik MLs in these stories have magical powers that can distinguish between shy (???) consent and non consent but ew it leaves a nasty taste in my mouth. bye.

[collapse]

The Ugly

Spoiler

I honestly don't really hate any of the 'villains' except Empress Dowager Yang and Old Madam Huo Xue-shi because wow those b*tches are stinkyyy. Even Cheng Yumo was just a little s*upid, not purely malicious and ill-intentioned. Ok let me rant about Huo Changyuan that s*upid whore.

What an absolutely piece of glorified cow dung. No matter how great (cough decent) he is, his relationship with his mother is an absolute red flag. Dude can't say no to his mom and will always defend her whiny ass. He even pushed his wife into a miscarriage for his mother and had the nerve to resent her when she became spiteful because of it. At this point in the story, HCY already had memories of his previous life where he was married to his beloved wife Cheng Yujin and lost her to dystocia because of his mentally handicapped mother. You'd think that with this example put out before him, he'd be a little more cautious with leaving her alone with his new wife Cheng Yumo but nah. Dude is forever stuck on the mentality of woe is me woohoohoo like damn my mom can never seem to get along with anyone I'm close to 🤔 surely there's a common denominator here somewhere damn I dont understand 😔

[collapse]
<<less
3 Likes · Like Permalink | Report
Leave a Review (Guidelines)
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.